New Swiss Re sigma Study Examines Impact of Inflation on Insurers

Swiss Rre has issued a timely new sigma study , “The impact of inflation on insurers,” which examines “recent commodity price spikes and the current easy monetary policy” that have “increased inflation concerns.”

Swiss Re underscored the fact that “many insurers have identified it as one of their key risks.” The study found that “insurers can limit the impact of inflation on investment returns, asset valuations and future insurance liabilities by using inflation hedges, adding index clauses to contracts and buying reinsurance.”

Inflation refers to the increases in prices for goods and services. “It impacts insurers’ claims and general expenses, the value of liabilities and, less directly, the value of assets,” said Swiss Re. “Growth in insurers’ claims costs has historically exceeded inflation due to additional factors, referred to as ‘social cost escalations.’ These social cost escalations, which are in addition to inflation costs, include the effects of increased litigation, changes in social norms, and rising expenses for medical treatment.”

Inflation affects life and non-life insurers differently. The study notes that “for non-life insurers, unanticipated inflation leads to higher claims costs, thereby eroding profitability.”

Thomas Holzheu, one of the authors of the new sigma study, explained: “Extended periods of accelerating inflation are especially problematic for long-tail lines of business. Insurers can mitigate the impact by adjusting premium rates, but sometimes this is not possible if regulation or the competitive environment do not allow for such adjustments.”

For life insurers, both inflation and deflation are risks. Inflation is often accompanied by rising interest rates, which reduce the value of return guarantees. Rising inflation can have a negative effect on demand, and may lead to policyholders cancelling their policies as well as increasing costs for insurers. In the case of deflation, or if very low inflation persists, interest rates tend to fall.

Kurt Karl, Swiss Re’s Chief US Economist and another of the study’s authors, pointed out that this “makes it more difficult for life insurers with large portfolios of minimum interest rate guarantee savings products to earn the appropriate asset returns.”

There are options available to mitigate the risks of inflation. David Laster, another of the study’s authors, explained: “On the asset side, insurers can invest in commodities, real estate and inflation indexed bonds, which we find to be the most viable inflation hedges. These investments have performed well during periods of high inflation.”

Insurers can also modify insurance contracts to shorten the tail and hence the development risk. Holzheu stated; “Insurers can introduce ‘claims made’ policies or sunset clauses to address the issue of latent claims. They can also add index clauses linking premiums, limits and deductibles/retention to an inflation-related index.”

Another option available is the purchase of reinsurance to offer protection “against inflation surprises. It is particularly helpful in emerging markets, where the risk of high inflation is greatest.”

Karl added: “While aggressive monetary policies and record government spending have triggered concerns that inflation could sharply increase, this is unlikely in the next 1 to 3 years because unemployment rates are elevated and there are few capacity constraints. But inflation could rise if monetary policy remains loose for too long and growth accelerates rapidly.”

Source: Swiss Re