Guy Carpenter Report Finds Lloyd’s Seeking to Improve ‘Competitiveness’

A new report on the Lloyd’s insurance market by Guy Carpenter & Co. finds that “Lloyd’s is looking to improve its global competitiveness despite mounting challenges including low investment returns, record catastrophe losses, subdued economic growth in developed markets and uncertainty over the future of the euro zone.”

The report – Lloyd’s: A Vision for Targeted Growth – provides an analysis of Lloyd’s operational performance, growth within the sector and explores how changes to the Market’s strategy will impact key players within the insurance industry.

Guy Carpenter described the report as detailing “how emerging market expansion, coupled with consolidation of its presence in established markets, will be the key driver in positioning Lloyd’s to remain the industry’s preeminent global hub for specialist insurance and reinsurance. This long-term strategy, coined ‘Vision 2025,’ will seek to further diversify Lloyd’s capital base and provide new growth opportunities amidst uncertain market conditions.”

The report also notes that Lloyd’s recorded a pre-tax loss of £516 million [$816 million], representing a 2.8 percent return on capital. 2011 is regarded as the second-costliest year for natural catastrophe claims in the history of the insurance industry. Lloyd’s faced a record-breaking £4.6 billion [$7.277 billion] in catastrophe-related losses in 2011, an increase of £2.2 billion [$3.48 billion] the previous year.

As a result Guy Carpenter noted that “Lloyd’s combined ratio jumped to 106.8 percent, up from 93.3 percent in the previous year, as a result of an exceptionally high number of large loss events including the Australian floods, New Zealand and Japanese earthquakes, and United States tornado losses.

“In 2011, about three-quarters of Lloyd’s business centered in developed markets such as the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Europe. As part of the Market’s long-term strategy, Lloyd’s will continue to expand its presence in growth markets such as China, Latin America, India and the Middle East.

“The 2011 investment return was 1.9 percent and weaker compared to previous years but the Market’s investment strategy has partially insulated it from some of the more damaging volatility seen across a number of markets since the onset of the financial crisis in 2008 and continuing through 2011.”

Lloyd’s, however, continued to attract investors. Its “capacity nearly doubled between 2007 and 2012, growing from £15.7 billion to £24.0 billion [$24.837 billion to $37.968 billion]. Between 2009 and 2010, capacity jumped 35 percent year-on-year but in 2011 and 2012, Lloyd’s only saw increases of 1 percent and 3 percent year-on-year respectively.”

The report also points out that “despite the large losses sustained in 2011, Lloyd’s capital levels have remained robust and have significantly increased over the last five years.”

Some issues, however, do pose problems. The protracted implementation of the Solvency II regulations is one. It adds “uncertainty to the industry and may reduce competitiveness and profits in the short to medium-term as insurers adjust their structures to comply with new capital adequacy levels that have yet to be confirmed,” Guy Carpenter said.
.
The implementation of Solvency II is one of Lloyd’s top priorities. The London Market “will continue to lobby the Financial Services Authority (FSA) to ensure Solvency II and other planned European regulations are appropriate for Lloyd’s and to fully understand the impact they will have on Lloyd’s international licenses.”

Matthew Day, Senior Vice President and EMEA Business Intelligence Practice Leader, stated, “Lloyd’s has remained resilient in spite of challenging global market conditions and significant catastrophe losses, but will need to continue to expand its global reach in order to maintain this competitiveness. Now, perhaps more than ever, it is essential to balance this need for growth and diversification while diligently managing risk.

“The Vision 2025 plan provides a clear roadmap for Lloyd’s to leverage its existing structure and strengths to break through to a new frontier of diverse emerging economies.”

Source: Guy Carpenter