Insurance Execs’ Midlife Crisis Cure: Four AIG, ACE Veterans Join Startup P2P Insurer Lemonade

An instech startup looking to disrupt the property/casualty insurance industry with a new business model has turned to four seasoned insurance executives from traditional carriers AIG and ACE Insurance to round out its executive team.

Lemonade, the peer-to-peer (P2P) insurance carrier set to launch in the first half of this year, has named Ty Sagalow, a 25-year senior executive with American International Group (AIG), as its chief insurance officer.

The New York-based startup has also attracted three other seasoned insurance executives — Robert Giurlando and James Hageman from ACE Insurance and Ron Topping, also from AIG — to join its small band of technologists.

It wasn’t easy to find experienced people in the conservative insurance industry who were willing to join a startup, according to Daniel Schreiber, one of the entrepreneurs behind the creation of Lemonade.

“Insurance professionals are typically conservative, which is not typically characteristic of a startup,” he said.

Schreiber said he joked during the search process that what Lemonade needed was people “going through a midlife crisis,” insurance executives who wanted to reinvent themselves and the very industry in which they had achieved success and prominence.

He wanted insurance professionals “schooled in insurance and who came up through the ranks” who were now looking for “something fresh.”

Insurance Hires

He thinks he has found four:

“I joined Lemonade because only a company born of technology, the sharing economy and behavioral economics can truly re-architect what insurance should look like,” Sagalow said in the announcement.

Sagalow said that at AIG and Zurich he spent his career “pushing the limits of innovation within Big Insurance” before concluding that “true disruptive innovation is almost impossible within the framework of legacy carriers.”

Balancing Act

While his company wants to represent a new way of doing things, tech entrepreneur Schreiber said he and his tech entrepreneur business partner Shai Wininger need insurance experience to counter their insurance “naiveté.” The AIG and ACE veterans should also help reassure investors, customers and regulators, he said.

 Shai Wininger (l) and Daniel Schreiber, founders of P2P insurer Lemonade
Shai Wininger (l) and Daniel Schreiber, founders of P2P insurer Lemonade

“That these executives turned away from traditional carriers speaks volumes about how insurance veterans see the state of the industry,” Schreiber said. “That they chose Lemonade is both a vote of confidence in the potential of peer-to-peer insurance, and the surest way to make it a reality.”

The Lemonade founder said he believes most people have a “propensity for innovation” but they need to be in an environment that brings it out. “The culture of the company matters,” he said.

According to Schreiber, while there may not be many insurance executives looking for a new thrill, there also aren’t many places like Lemonade where they can go.


Schreiber was asked about the lack of diversity in his executive suite with this hiring of four males. He said that is a reflection of the insurance industry senior talent pool and not of his company, whose 20 employees he said represent a diverse and eclectic workforce. He said his firm has hired technologists, designers, actuaries and other insurance professionals and has been able to attract a diverse group of people.

He said the company is done hiring for now but it will be adding employees as necessary as the company grows.

Lemonade’s founders enjoy the backing of Aleph and Sequoia Capital. They raised $13 million in initial funding. Lemonade will be a New York licensed insurance carrier, not a broker.

The founders claim that their P2P business model and technology will alter the current industry’s bureaucracy and structure “in ways not available to the legacy insurance carriers.”

Typically P2P sites invite users to form small groups of policyholders who pay premiums into a pool to pay claims. If there is money left in the pool at the end of the policy period, the members get money back.

Lemonade will not be the first P2P insurance venture. Germany has friendsurance (founded in 2010), the United Kingdom has Guevara, and China has TongJuBao. It’s not yet known in what ways Lemonade will compare to these and other P2P ventures, some of which act as brokers, not carriers.