FEMA CHANGES RULES MID-STREAM; WHO SHOULD PAY?

July 24, 2006

FEMA recently issued new flood maps that require people in many parts of New Orleans to elevate their houses, according to Jeff Albright, chief executive officer of the Independent Insurance Agents of Louisiana. “When you talk of raising a structure up off the ground, its very expensive. I’ve heard estimates ranging from $25,000 to $60,000. Obviously that is a very difficult situation for policyholders to deal with,” he said. Albright asked, “If policyholders are not able to have their houses elevated, will flood insurance be available through the NFIP?”

There are a lot of public policy questions related to the virtue of rebuilding an area that is below sea level and then providing flood insurance to it, Albright said. “A lot of people who are not from [New Orleans] ask the question: Why do people live below sea level? And, why should we rebuild that? And, why should those people get any help?”

According to Albright, people in New Orleans bought homes and other property based on the existing FEMA flood maps and based on assurances from the Army Corps of Engineers that the levees could withstand a Category 3 hurricane. He said people made rational decisions based on the information they had at the time.

However, “now FEMA is revising their maps and saying, ‘Oops, it needs to be three feet higher.’ And, ‘Oops, the levees didn’t hold. By the way, we don’t think its going to hold the next time a Cat 3 storm hits.’ And ‘We’re not sure we’re going to enhance the levees to make them what we told you they were to begin with,'” Albright said.

“Whose fault is that? he asked. “Is it the fault of the policyholders that made rational decisions based upon assurances from the federal government, FEMA and the Corps of Engineers? Or is it the fault of the federal government for allowing them to commit major assets and properties that weren’t as protected as they said they were?”

And, as always, the question comes down to: who is going to pay for it? “Are we going to make those people in New Orleans suffer enormous financial loss?” asked Albright.

That remains to be seen.

Topics Flood

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

From This Issue

Insurance Journal Magazine July 24, 2006
July 24, 2006
Insurance Journal Magazine

2006 Excess, Surplus and Specialty Markets Directory, Vol. I