Brazil Judge Orders Vale to Pay Damages to Families of Victims of 2019 Mining Disaster

June 11, 2021

BRASILIA – A regional labor judge has ordered Brazilian miner Vale SA to pay 1 million reais ($197,240) in compensation to each of the families of 131 employees killed in the collapse of a mining dam in 2019.

The disaster in Brumadinho, Minas Gerais state, killed 270 people in Brazil’s most deadly mining tragedy has hampered Vale’s performance for two years as it was forced to curb production amid new safety protocols.

Judge Vivianne Celia Ferreira Ramos Correa on Wednesday agreed to the request of the Brumadinho iron mining workers union that the compensation be paid to the estate or heirs of the victims of the disaster, according to the ruling seen by Reuters.

Her decision can be appealed by the company. Vale said it will study the judge’s decision.

Vale said in a statement that “it is sensitive to the situation of those affected by the collapse of the B1 dam and has been reaching agreements with the workers’ families since 2019 to guarantee quick and complete reparation.”

The company argued that it has already paid more than 2 billion reais in civil and labor indemnities associated with the disaster, after having signed agreements with more than 1,600 relatives of victims.

The union’s lawyer, Maximiliano Garcez, welcomed the ruling as “humanist” and told Reuters he originally asked for compensation of 3 million reais per deceased worker.

The dam collapse destroyed houses and other building and polluted rivers causing lasting environmental damage in the region.

In February, Vale said it had reached a 37.7 billion real ($7 billion) agreement with prosecutors and the state of Minas Gerais to settle claims stemming from the disaster.

The government of Minas Gerais said the agreement did not set a ceiling on potential costs associated with environmental cleanup, which Vale will have to cover.

($1 = 5.0700 reais) (Reporting by Anthony Boadle, editing by Nick Zieminski)

Photograph: In this Jan. 28, 2019 file photo, firefighters are resupplied as they search for victims of the Vale dam collapse in Brumadinho, Brazil. The Jan. 25 breach of the dam, which is owned and operated by Vale SA, unleashed tens of thousands of pounds (kilograms) of reddish-brown mud over a wide area in Brumadinho. Photo credit: AP Photo/Leo Correa, File.


Topics Legislation Mining

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.