• MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
Insurance Journal - Property Casualty Industry News

Featured Stories

  • New Federal Flood Rating Plan Ready
  • N.Y. City Loses Global Warming Suit
  • News
  • Markets

Current Magazine

current magazine
  • Read Online
  • Subscribe
  • Front Page
    • National
    • International
    • Most Popular
    • Magazine
    • Forums
    • Blogs
    • Videos/Podcasts
    • Newsletters
  • News
    • Most Popular
    • National
    • International
    • East
    • Midwest
    • South Central
    • Southeast
    • West
  • Magazines
    • East
    • Midwest
    • South Central
    • Southeast
    • West
    • Subscribe
  • Research
  • Directories
  • Jobs
  • Features
    • Events
    • Forums
    • Insurance Twitter
    • Market Directories
    • Quotes
    • Polls
    • Rankings & Awards
  • Subscribe

Next LGBT Legal Battle for Supreme Court Will Be Religious Exemptions: Analysis

By Lawrence Hurley and Jan Wolfe | June 16, 2020
Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
Email to a friend Facebook Tweet LinkedIn Print Article
  • Article
  • 36 Comments

The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling protecting LGBT rights in the workplace sets the stage for another major legal fight over the scope of religious-rights exemptions to certain federal laws that could dilute the landmark decision’s impact.

The justices ruled 6-3 on Monday that federal employment law safeguards gay and transgender employees from discrimination but failed to resolve some related legal questions. One of them is whether the court, which has 5-4 conservative majority, will expand the ability of individuals, businesses and organizations to cite religious beliefs when contesting government actions such as enforcement of anti-discrimination laws.

In their next term, which starts in October, the justices will decide whether Philadelphia violated the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment rights of freedom of speech and religion in how it dealt with an organization that is part of the city’s Roman Catholic archdiocese. City officials barred Catholic Social Services from participating in Philadelphia’s foster-care program because the organization barred same-sex couples from serving as foster parents, a violation of its anti-discrimination policies.

A ruling in favor of Catholic Social Services could make it easier for people to cite religious beliefs when seeking exemptions from widely applicable laws, potentially even in employment cases.

“There are absolutely ways it could come out that would mean there’s a constitutional right to discriminate,” said American Civil Liberties Union lawyer James Esseks as the justices consider various options for deciding the dispute.

Catholic Social Services has asked the court to overturn a 1990 Supreme Court ruling in the case Employment Division v. Smith that limited such exemptions. Overturning that ruling “would open up a whole panoply of religious defenses,” said John Bursch, a lawyer with the conservative Christian legal group Alliance Defending Freedom.

RELIGIOUS FREEDOM RESTORATION ACT

Even if the court does not do so, employers can still mount religious-based defenses under a 1993 federal law called the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

R.G. and G.R. Harris Funeral Homes Inc of Detroit, one of the employers named in the discrimination cases the Supreme Court decided on Monday, had cited that law in its defense after a transgender former employee, Aimee Stephens, sued the company.

The Supreme Court did not decide the Religious Freedom Restoration Act issues. Justice Neil Gorsuch, the ruling’s author, wrote that “how these doctrines protecting religious liberty interact with Title VII (the section of the civil rights law at issue) are questions for future cases.”

Employers have a “pretty good start” in making a religious rights claim following a 2014 Supreme Court ruling that allowed that law to be invoked by companies, University of Miami School of Law constitutional law professor Caroline Mala Corbin said.

Beyond the religious rights issue, there is the question of whether other federal laws barring sex-based discrimination, including those involving bias in housing and education, should be interpreted as covering sexual orientation and gender identity. If so, that could affect the ongoing dispute over whether transgender students can be barred from using the bathroom that corresponds with their gender identity, as a Virginia school district did in a case pending in the lower courts.

The Supreme Court in recent years has sent mixed messages on the intersection between gay and religious rights. It backed gay rights in a series of rulings culminating in the 2015 decision legalizing same-sex marriage nationwide. But it also bolstered religious rights, including in the 2014 ruling allowing owners of businesses to raise religious objections against the government.

The justices in 2018 handed a victory on narrow grounds to a Colorado baker who refused based on his Christian beliefs to make a wedding cake for a gay couple, but stopped short of setting a major precedent letting people claim religious exemptions from anti-discrimination laws.

Central to those cases was conservative Justice Anthony Kennedy, who retired in 2018. President Donald Trump appointed Brett Kavanaugh to replace him. Kennedy wrote the gay marriage ruling, joining with the court’s liberals, but joined with his fellow conservatives in the religious-rights and baker decisions.

Kavanaugh, like Gorsuch, has shown sympathy toward religious liberty claims. Kavanaugh dissented in Monday’s ruling.

Bursch said there is a “strong possibility” that the 6-3 vote breakdown in Monday’s ruling would not be replicated when the court decides the foster care case, with a ruling due by the end of June 2021.

(Reporting by Lawrence Hurley and Jan Wolfe; Editing by Will Dunham)

Copyright 2021 Reuters. Click for restrictions.

Was this article valuable?

Thank you! Please tell us what we can do to improve this article.

Thank you! % of people found this article valuable. Please tell us what you liked about it.

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Impact of Brexit on City of London Is Worse than Expected: Study
Update: Aon Offers to Sell Assets to Gain EU Antitrust Approval for $30B Willis Bid
Two Die in Tesla Crash in Texas
Transportation Insurer Lancer to Merge Into Core Specialty

The most important insurance news,
in your inbox every business day.

Get the insurance industry's trusted newsletter

Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
Email to a friend Facebook Tweet LinkedIn Print Article
  • Categories: National NewsTopics: Catholic Social Services, gay foster care, job discrimination, LGBT civil rights protections, LGBTQ workplace protections, religious exemption, religious freedom, Religious Freedom Restoration Act
  • Have a hot lead? Email us at newsdesk@insurancejournal.com

Latest Comments

  • June 17, 2020 at 4:48 pm
    Jon says:
    "No laws are EVER passed for whatever comes up in the future that isn’t specifically and clearly stated in the law." Which is why the 2nd amendment didn't perceive the futur... read more
  • June 17, 2020 at 4:30 pm
    Craig Winston Cornell says:
    What a BSer you are Rosenblatt. I always knew you weren't the sharpest guy on the internet, but now I am thinking you are dishonest too. Laws are passed at the time they are p... read more
  • June 17, 2020 at 11:22 am
    Jon says:
    Trying to excuse bigotry with "biblical reasons" is garbage. Your religion doesn't justify you being a homophobic bigot. YOUR post is not needed. Jack's post is not needed. If... read more

Add a CommentSee All Comments (36)Add a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

More News
Businesses Turned to Risk Management Technology More During Pandemic
P/C Insurers Returned $13B in Premiums Due to COVID-19 Reduced Exposures
How U.S. Plans to Protect Power Grid From Foreign Hackers
People Moves: Liberty Specialty Promotes Warren; GC FAC’s Smith to Miller; Everest’s Geddes to MS Amlin; Pro Global Hires; Generali Promotions
More News Features

Read This Next

  • Next LGBT Legal Battle for Supreme Court Will Be Religious Exemptions: Analysis
  • Massachusetts Shoe Company Exec to Plead Guilty to Embezzling $30M
  • J.M. Wilson Acquires Wisconsin's Transcom General Agency
  • Florida Drives Toward Repeal of Motor Vehicle No-Fault Law
  • NAIC Data: Florida Property Lawsuits Total 76% of Insurer Litigation in U.S.

Insurance Jobs

  • Senior Integrated Creative Project Manager - Chicago, IL
  • Android Mobile Software Engineer-REMOTE - Dallas, TX
  • Customer Service Assistant, Part Time Work from Home - Hartford, CT
  • Senior Global Actuarial Analyst - New York, NY
  • Lead Java Software Engineer – Java Web Services-REMOTE - Dallas, TX
MyNewMarkets
  • Emerging Pandemic Risks From Covid, Cyber, Civil Unrest, Mergers, and More... Part 2
  • Emerging Pandemic Risks From Covid, Cyber, Civil Unrest, Mergers, and More... Part 1
  • 3 Ways Insurtech Can Help Agents Thrive in 2021 and Beyond
  • Cyber E&O Incidents Worsened in 2020: Aon
  • Workers' Compensation Underwriters Under the Gun to Understand Pandemic Data
Claims Journal
  • Ga. Supreme: GEICO Must Pay $2.7M After Failing to Accept $30K Settlement Offer
  • Tesla Drives on Autopilot Through a Regulatory Grey Zone
  • Inferno on Cape Town's Table Mountain Rages Out of Control
  • U.S. Unveils Plan to Protect Power Grid From Foreign Hackers
  • J&J, Other Drugmakers Go to Trial in California in $50B Case Over 'Deadly Legacy' of Opioids
Academy of Insurance education
  • April 22 E&O - From the Tower to the Trenches
  • April 27 The Who, What, Why, and How of 21st Century Insurance Professional Onboarding
  • May 4 CGL Master Class - Additional Insured Endorsements
  • May 6 Our Legal System and Legal Liability

Insurance News

  • News by Region
  • News by Topic
  • Yesterday

Site Search

Features

  • Insurance Markets Directory
  • Forums
  • A.M. Best Company Ratings
  • Industry Events
  • Agencies For Sale
  • Newswire
  • Insurance Jobs
  • Rankings & Awards

Connect with us

  • Email Newsletters
  • Magazine Subscriptions
  • For Your Website
  • RSS Feeds
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Do Not Sell My Info

Insurance Journal

  • Submit News
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Reprints
  • Link to Us
  • Contact Us

Wells Media Group Network

  • Insurance Journal
  • MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
© 2021 by Wells Media Group, Inc. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Site Map

We have updated our privacy policy to be more clear and meet the new requirements of the GDPR. By continuing to use our site, you accept our revised Privacy Policy.