Shepherd Corrals Another SW Florida Agency—Responsive Insurance in Naples

June 5, 2026

Shepherd Insurance has continued its expansion in southwest Florida, this time with the acquisition of Responsive Insurance, an agency with offices in Estero and Naples, the company said this week.

Matt Nance, owner of Responsive, and his team will stay with the agency.

The merger comes less than two weeks after Indiana-headquartered Shepherd Insurance, ranked as one of the largest groups of independent agencies, announced it had acquired Arnold Insurance in Port Charlotte, Florida.

Shepherd, founded in 1977, now has eight Florida agency offices, new Bradenton office space, and 45 offices in six states, writing commercial and personal insurance, and offering employee benefits. Quinn Shepherd is CEO.

Topics Florida

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.