He oversaw Citizens Property Insurance Corp. during one of the most turbulent periods for Florida’s insurance market, seeing the state-created insurer grow to record sizeāthen shrink to its smallest level in more than 20 years.
And now Citizens’ CEO Tim Cerio is stepping down.
“After nearly four incredibly rewarding years as your president/CEO and executive director, I will be leaving Citizens in January to return to the private sector,” Cerio said in a message to Citizens staff on Friday, Nov. 20.
Cerio, who took over in January 2023 after former CEO Barry Gilway retired, did not indicate what endeavors he may pursue. He is a lawyer who served as general counsel for Citizens in 2015 and 2016. It’s also unclear who may be considered to replace Cerio at Citizens.
“Over the next several weeks I will be working with our Board of Governors on a transition plan, so stay tuned for more specifics,” Cerio’s message reads.

Cerio, who earned his bachelor’s degree and his law degree from the University of Florida, took the reins near the worst of the Florida property insurance crisis, in which 10 insurance carriers went insolvent and rates had soared. That caused policyholders across the state to move to Citizens, where premium increases are limited by statute.
By September 2023, Citizens’ policy count reached more than 1.4 million, making it the largest property insurer in the state, by far. After enactment of 2022 and 2023 legislative changes that stemmed runaway claims litigation, Citizens has shrunk to 216,447 policies in force as of the end of October this year.
“The reforms enacted by the Florida Legislature provided the tools to change course,” Cerio noted in his text message. “But legislation alone doesn’t create results.”
He said Citizens has become a more-focused organization while it has maintained financial discipline and readiness. He thanked staff members for their hard work and flexibility through the years.
Shrinking an organization can be more challenging than growing one, he said. “Many of you took on new responsibilities, adapted to changing processes and supported colleagues through transitions,” he noted.
Citizens Board Chairman Carlos Beruff praised Cerio’s leadership.
“Mr. Cerio has been a steady, principled leader for Citizens during one of the most critical periods in the history of Florida’s property insurance market,” Beruff said in a statement sent by Citizens Friday morning. “Tim has a long track record of public service, and he leaves Citizens stronger and better positioned for the future. On behalf of the Board, I thank him for his service to Citizens and to the people of Florida.”
Cerio will continue as a member of Governor-elect Byron Donalds’ transition team and as vice chairman of the Board of Governors of the State University System, the Citizens press release noted.
Top photo: Cerio at the Florida Chamber of Commerce Insurance Summit (IJ photo)
Topics Florida
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Allstate’s AI Ecosystem to Include a Personal Agentic Assistant for Customers
GTA VI Frenzy Spotlights Potential Insurance Risks Lurking in Digital Infrastructure
JPMorgan, Visa Warn of Cyberattack That Hit Outside Vendor
Planes Collide at Miami Airport, Weeks After Deadly Amazon Crash


