Featured Stories

Insurance Industry Rankings & Awards

2006 Top 100 Property/Casualty Agencies

Note: You are viewing an archived version of this list from a previous year.
Go to the 2025 Top 100 Property/Casualty Agencies List.

Explore our other lists by visiting our Rankings & Awards page or by selecting one below.

For the most recent insurance agency rankings, see our 2010 top 100 agencies list.

More than two-thirds (64 percent) of the agencies and brokerages listed in Insurance Journal’s 2007 Top 100 Property Casualty Independent Agencies report they increased their P/C premium volume in 2006 over 2005.

For the complete special report, see our April 9, 2007 full issue.

Other years: 2009 | 2008 | 2007

2006 Rank 2005 Rank Agency Name Total 2006 P/C Premium Written 2005 P/C Premium % Premium Change 2006 Other than P/C Premium 2006 P/C Revenue Total Employees Main Office Web site
1 Lockton Cos. LLC*

$7.0 billion Kansas City, Mo.
2 Alliant Insurance Services

$1.4 billion Newport Beach, Calif.
3 The Leavitt Group

$1.0 billion Cedar City, Utah
4 Keystone Insurers Group

$790.0 million Northumberland, Pa.
5 InterWest Insurance Srvs. Inc.

$739.2 million Sacramento, Calif.
6 Hylant Group Inc.

$642.0 million Toledo, Ohio
7 Beecher Carlson

$622.4 million Atlanta, Ga.
8 Keenan & Associates

$618.0 million Torrance, Calif.
9 Insurance Office of America Inc.

$559.7 million Longwood, Fla.
10 The IMA Financial Group Inc.*

$530.0 million Wichita, Kan.
11 Heffernan Group

$524.0 million Walnut Creek, Calif.
12 J. Smith Lanier & Co.

$503.8 million West Point, Ga.
13 Bollinger Inc.

$472.0 million Short Hills, N.J.
14 The NIA Group LLC

$426.3 million Paramus, N.J.
15 Rutherfoord Cos.*

$420.7 million Roanoke, Va.
16 Southwest Business Corp.

$385.9 million San Antonio, Texas
17 Woodruff-Sawyer & Co.*

$384.0 million San Francisco, Calif.
18 Neace Lukens Holding Co.

$328.6 million Louisville, Ky.
19 Van Gilder Insurance Corp.

$309.2 million Denver, Colo.
20 Satellite Agency Network Group Inc.*

$303.0 million Hampton, N.H.
21 Renaissance Insurance Group*

$300.0 million Wellesley, Mass.
22 Scott Insurance

$300.0 million Lynchburg, Va.
23 RCM&D Inc.

$291.6 million Baltimore, Md.
24 The Horton Group

$291.0 million Orland Park, Ill.
25 Bowen, Miclette & Britt Inc.

$289.8 million Houston, Texas
26 Assurance Agency Ltd.

$284.5 million Schaumburg, Ill.
27 North American Group

$284.2 million Oklahoma City, Okla.
28 Marshall & Sterling

$283.2 million Poughkeepsie, N.Y.
29 The Mahoney Group*

$280.0 million Casa Grande, Ariz.
30 Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc.*

$261.5 million Syracuse, N.Y.
31 The Graham Co.*

$258.0 million Philadelphia, Pa.
32 Starkweather & Shepley Inc.

$255.5 million East Providence, R.I.
33 McQueary Henry Bowles Troy LLP

$255.3 million Dallas, Texas
34 Insurors Group LLC*

$252.1 million Bryan, Texas
35 Great Florida Insurance*

$250.0 million Stuart, Fla.
36 Iroquois Group Inc.

$248.3 million Olean, N.Y.
37 Insurance Alliance of Central Pa. Inc.*

$238.9 million Camp Hill, Pa. w
38 Cobbs, Allen & Hall Inc.

$214.9 million Birmingham, Ala.
39 Roger Bouchard Insurance Inc.

$208.3 million Clearwater, Fla.
40 United Agencies Inc.

$200.0 million Pasadena, Calif.
41 Parker, Smith & Feek

$187.8 million Bellevue, Wash.
42 Dawson Insurance Inc.*

$187.7 million Rocky River, Ohio
43 Professional Insurance Assoc. Inc.

$185.0 million San Carlos, Calif.
44 Higginbotham & Assoc. Inc.

$184.2 million Fort Worth, Texas
45 Advanced Insurance Underwriters LLC

$182.2 million Hollywood, Fla.
46 Lawley Service Inc.

$180.0 million Buffalo, N.Y.
47 HBA Insurance Group

$180.0 million Miami, Fla.
48 Westland Insurance Brokers

$176.0 million San Diego, Calif.
49 Robertson Ryan & Assoc. Inc.

$173.0 million Milwaukee, Wis.
50 Lovitt-Touche Inc.*

$172.8 million Tucson, Ariz.
51 SIA of N.C.*

$169.0 million Jacksonville, N.C.
52 Risk Transfer Holdings Inc.

$168.8 million Orlando, Fla.
53 Jenkins Athens Insurance Services Inc.

$164.6 million Concord, Calif.
54 Harden & Associates

$162.6 million Jacksonville, Fla.
55 J. Rolfe Davis Insurance

$156.2 million Maitland, Fla.
56 Houchens Insurance Group

$154.0 million Bowling Green, Ky.
57 Bainswest Inc.*

$150.4 million Tulsa, Okla.
58 The Daniel and Henry Co.

$141.2 million St. Louis, Mo.
59 RJF Agencies Inc.

$139.5 million Minneapolis, Minn.
60 Bolton & Co.

$136.4 million Pasadena, Calif.
61 Hamilton Insurance Agency

$135.0 million Fairfax, Va.
62 California Insurance Center

$133.5 million Lafayette, Calif.
63 Sinclair Insurance Group Inc.

$131.0 million Wallingford, Conn.
64 R&R Insurance Services

$130.9 million Waukesha, Wis.
65 Swantner & Gordon Insurance Agency

$129.0 million Corpus Christi, Texas
66 Mang Insurance Agency

$125.0 million Sidney, N.Y.
67 Hamilton Brewart Insurance Agency $

$118.0 million Upland, Calif.
68 Gregory & Appel Insurance

$115.5 million Indianapolis, Ind.
69 TrueNorth

$115.2 million Cedar Rapids, Iowa
70 Gateway Insurance Agency

$114.6 million Ft. Lauderdale, Fla.
71 Gowrie, Barden & Brett Inc.

$112.0 million Westbrook, Conn.
72 Schiff, Kreidler-Shell Inc.*

$111.3 million Cincinnati, Ohio
73 Lyons Cos.*

$110.0 million Wilmington, Del.
74 Scirocco Financial Group Inc.

$108.1 million Hasbrouck Heights, N.J.
75 TIS Insurance Services Inc.

$105.8 million Knoxville, Tenn.
76 Brower Insurance Agency LLC*

$104.5 million Dayton, Ohio
77 Cook, Hall & Hyde Inc.

$103.1 million East Hampton, N.Y.
78 nsgroup Inc.

$103.0 million Houston, Texas
79 PrideMark-Everest Insurance*

$102.0 million Santa Ana, Calif.
80 Anco Insurance Managers Ltd.

$101.1 million Bryan, Texas
81 Ag States Group

$99.3 million St. Paul, Minn.
82 Curley Insurance Group

$98.4 million Dallas, Texas
83 Wood Gutmann & Bogart Ins. Brokers

$98.1 million Tustin, Calif.
84 Lipscomb & Pitts Insurance

$97.7 million Memphis, Tenn.
85 Universal Insurance Services Inc.

$96.7 million Grand Rapids, Mich. w
86 Mortenson, Matzelle & Meldrum Inc.

$95.7 million Madison, Wis.
87 Lanier Upshaw Inc.

$93.6 million Lakeland, Fla.
88 TWFG Insurance Services

$92.5 million The Woodlands, Texas
89 CFR

$91.8 million Tulsa, Okla.
90 SIA of Wis., Minn. and Mich..s U.P.*

$90.2 million Green Bay, Wis.
91 AH&T Insurance

$90.1 million Leesburg, Va.
92 Eustis Insurance & Benefits Inc.

$88.0 million New Orleans, La.
93 North Florida Agency Network*

$87.6 million Tallahassee, Fla.
94 The Advantage Group*

$85.3 million Seattle, Wash.
95 Comegys Insurance Agency*

$84.8 million St. Petersburg, Fla.
96 Chapman & Associates

$80.9 million Pasadena, Calif.
97 Dean & Draper Insurance Agency LP

$80.0 million Houston, Texas
98 Kapnick Insurance Group

$80.0 million Adrian, Mich.
99 Agents Helping Agents Inc.*

$79.9 million N Louisville, Ky.
100 John M. Glover Agency

$79.8 million Norwalk, Conn.

* = Identified as having an affiliation with an independent network or cluster group. Employee count for these does not necessarily include all affiliates responsible for total premiums written.