Backed by government policy and growing public support, demand for technology that is both clean and sustainable has increased substantially in the United States, Europe, Asia and other parts of the world over the last decade.
As the market for clean technology has expanded, it has attracted interest from investors who see potential in a promising new sector. Global venture capital into the aptly named “clean tech” sector has increased from a little more than $500 million in 2001 to nearly $8 billion in 2010, according to industry market research firm Cleantech Group LLC.
New clean tech businesses have been formed as a result of this wave of investment and many are seeking to establish a supply chain that includes manufacturing facilities outside of the United States, where it is less expensive to build and operate facilities and there is a wealth of technical expertise.
Businesses that are planning to establish manufacturing facilities outside the United States need to be aware of the challenges as well as the advantages of operating in foreign countries and take steps to manage the risk and reduce the possibility of a loss.
The Clean Tech Revolution
Clean technology (or “clean tech”) is a broad term that covers a wide range of technologies, products and processes that are renewable and seek to minimize impact on the environment while conserving natural resources.
Although solar panels and windmills are some of the most familiar clean technologies, clean tech products are used in a number of different industries from power generation and storage, to transportation, agriculture, water and wastewater treatment, and manufacturing. Other emerging clean technologies and innovations include fuel cells and advanced batteries for energy storage, compressed natural gas for fueling fleets of trucks, new lighting systems, and green roofs.
Demand for clean technologies has increased in the United States, as well as in Europe and Asia in the last decade, driven by a combination of government mandates and incentives as well as public and private financing.
In the United States, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, for instance, included more than $100 billion for the clean tech industry to be spent over several years, according to Cleantech.
At the state level, government also has helped to create demand for clean tech through its renewable portfolio standards (RPS). A renewable portfolio standard is a state policy that requires electricity providers to obtain a minimum percentage of their power from renewable sources by a certain date. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, there are 24 states plus the District of Columbia that have RPS policies in place. Five other states have nonbinding goals for adoption of renewable energy instead of an RPS.
California has been a big driver of demand with one of the most ambitious renewable energy standards and aggressive energy efficient building codes in the country. California last year raised the state’s renewable portfolio standard to 33 percent by 2020.
Outside of the United States, there has been a great deal of support from governmental agencies and government sponsored incentives for clean tech products and services. While North America accounted for 69 percent of the total global venture capital invested in 2010, Europe and Israel accounted for 21 percent and Asia for 10 percent, according to Cleantech.
European and Israeli companies raised $1.62 billion in venture capital in 2010, which represented a 7 percent increase in the number of deals completed, but a 7 percent decrease in capital committed.
In the initial public offering (IPO) market, the largest deal of the year was for Enel Green Power, the renewable energy unit of Italian utility Enel, which raised $3.6 billion on the Madrid and Milan stock exchanges.
China, however, has been gaining ground as a center for clean tech investment. In the IPO market, for instance, eight of the top 10 deals in 2010 were Chinese companies.
China also has become a top location for companies seeking to establish clean tech manufacturing facilities. These businesses are setting up operations in China where it is advantageous to operate and to link production to the global supply chain.
Before establishing facilities outside of the United States, however, businesses need to be aware of the risks they may face.
Two key areas of concern are:
• Construction and land use practices related to construction exposures and facility protection systems
• Third party liability practices for product quality and applicable standards.
Manufacturing facilities for clean tech businesses often have to meet higher standards than other general types of construction, but building standards in foreign countries may not be as stringent as they are in United States. These facilities also may require clean room environments, sprinkler systems or other types of specialized protection systems that are not standard for construction outside the United States or European Union.
Buildings that meet local building standards but not U.S. standards, or are not properly equipped with protection systems may be at increased risk of a loss. A delay or business interruption at a production plant also could result in violations of contractual obligations.
Manufacturers of clean tech products also have to meet exacting quality assurance procedures to satisfy global specifications. It is critical, for instance, for solar cells and wind turbine blades to meet required specifications because any component part that fails could cause a system failure and result in a loss.
Managing the Risks
To ensure that both construction and product quality standards are being met, businesses have to have people on the ground to oversee operations.
It is also important for businesses to enlist the assistance of professionals who know the language of the country where the manufacturing facilities are located and who have expertise in critical areas such as engineering and construction.
To find professionals with these qualifications, businesses can turn to their insurers for help. In some cases, insurers will have engineering and loss control expertise of their own. Other insurers are often familiar with local and international firms that could provide the needed services.
Businesses will also need a property insurance policy that includes protection against financial losses caused by an interruption of business activities because of a property loss. A local admitted policy will provide businesses with the insurance they need to be in compliance with local legal or marketplace requirements.
Unfortunately, these policies do not normally provide the level of insurance to which U.S. clients are accustomed. As such and in addition to locally admitted policies, multinationals also should purchase a controlled master policy (CMP) as part of their global program.
Other insurance features should also be considered. Research and development business interruption, for instance, helps protect against the loss of a product that was still in the research and development phase and had not yet begun to generate any revenue. Environmental insurance also may be appropriate for some clean tech businesses depending on the technologies and locations.
Clean tech businesses also may be required contractually to purchase errors and omissions (E&O) insurance to protect them against their liability to their customers because a product or service they provided is defective. Warranties are another type of risk management tool that may be needed as some financial groups have recently begun asking product suppliers to include 25-year warranties on their products.
When it comes to choosing an insurer, businesses should look for a carrier that has extensive experience working in countries outside of the United States, as well as world-class loss control and claims handling services.
As the clean tech industry grows and expands, it faces new exposures that call for careful planning and risk management. As this sector grows, agents and brokers also should take time to understand the industry, the variety of technologies, and the challenges both in the United States and abroad so they can help their clients manage risk.
Businesses that expand outside the United States face serious risks, but by taking the appropriate precautions, they can manage those risks and take advantage of the opportunities that a worldwide supply chain has to offer.
Ellis is a senior vice president of Chubb & Son, and manager of Multinational Risk Group – Global Accounts. Albertson is vice president, CleanTech Segment Leader, Chubb and Son.