Portland Firemen Say City Broke Contract

The city of Portland has been hit with a lawsuit filed by six firefighters who say they were ordered back to work even though they were sick or injured.

The lawsuit says the city broke a contract by requiring each of them to work in non-firefighting jobs for the city or have their disability benefits cut off. The lawsuit filed this week seeks $800,000 in damages for each of the six.

The men were ordered back to work following an investigation by The Oregonian newspaper. The series, which led to voter-approved reforms in November 2005, found that one in nine Portland police officers and firefighters was out on disability, and the injured workers were able to collect checks until retirement, even if they could earn a living in another job.

Several of the firefighters who brought the suit were found to be holding other jobs while continuing to collect disability benefits each month from the Portland Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Fund.

The lawsuit alleges that, in response to inquiries by the Oregonian, the six firefighters were forced to work for the city, forced to take early retirement or had their benefits terminated. They said they suffered permanent damage to their knees, shoulders and backs. One went on disability in 2000 after he tested positive for hepatitis C.

The attorney for the plaintiffs, Montgomery W. Cobb, declined comment.

Jenifer Johnston, a deputy city attorney, said the city will contest the lawsuit.

“We want people to be employed. That’s the goal of the program,” she said. “What we’re trying to do there seems pretty positive.”

Latest Comments

• October 21, 2008 at 2:45 am

  Mary B. says:

  Agreed Baxtor. These guys are criminals and should be treated as such. Either work or be fired. Hope the lawsuit is thrown out like the trash it is and hope these criminals ha... read more
• October 20, 2008 at 3:08 am

  Baxtor says:

  I hope the firefighter's get put in jail. Double dipping idiots. Kids look up to them. Working another job and still collecting benefits? Wrong wrong wrong. I'm sure they... read more
• October 20, 2008 at 2:28 am

  Jim bradley says:

  common on asking a publis employee to work at another job to save a city some money???????? doesn't not the city of Portland realize that the firemen have to be treayted like.... read more