State Farm VP Apologizes to Homeowner While Allstate Gets Grilled at Senate Hearing

It’s not just a few Florida-domiciled insurance carriers that have allegedly altered field adjusters’ reports on property damage in recent years. It’s also major national insurers, including Allstate and State Farm, adjusters and policyholders alleged at a U.S. Senate hearing this week marked by drama and political theater.

After hearing testimony from a North Carolina policyholder who said his Hurricane Helene-damaged home is still unrepaired, State Farm’s operations vice president took the extraordinary step of apologizing during the subcommittee hearing Tuesday.

“We have 66,000 employees. We’re human beings. We make mistakes. We made mistakes in the handling of this claim. These actions do not reflect the values of State Farm,” said company Vice President Michael Keating, who stood up and turned to address the insured, Jacob Vertel, of Asheville.

“On behalf of State Farm I want to sincerely apologize to Mr. and Mrs. Vertel,” Keating said, promising to resolve the claim.

But an Allstate Insurance executive at the hearing disputed some of the assertions made by a Georgia policyholder and the adjusters who worked her claim after a massive oak tree fell on the home.

“Some of what you heard today was not accurate,” Allstate’s Mike Fiato, chief claims officer, said during the hearing of the Disaster Management Subcommittee of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs. Fiato noted Allstate settled with the homeowners for about $100,000—something the policyholder did not reveal in her testimony Tuesday.

Allstate has declined to pay an additional $100,000 or more in non-structural or cosmetic restoration work, Fiato explained.

Nonetheless, Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., who has indicated he plans to run for president in 2028, scarcely let Fiato answer questions and accused Allstate of fraud.

“I have to notice that your (Allstate’s) profits have never been better. You made $4.6 billion in profits and your CEO, Tom Wilson, last year was paid $26 million,” said Hawley, chairman of the subcommittee. He asked why the policyholder could not get paid but the company CEO can. Fiato responded that Allstate had, in fact, paid the claim.

“No, you didn’t. You paid a paltry sum,” said Hawley, the former attorney general for Missouri. He went on to demand that Fiato reveal his own salary, which Fiato declined to provide.

The dramatic exchange came after two adjusters, one an independent adjuster who was hired by Allstate and the other who has worked mostly for Allstate in recent years, testified that Allstate reviewers or desk adjusters had repeatedly asked them to remove line items from storm damage estimates and to mischaracterize some types of damage.

“I was instructed to attribute cracked tiles to settling, and to show that the roof should be repaired, not replaced,” said independent adjuster Nick Schroeder, who worked the claim for Pilot Catastrophe Services, a claims adjusting firm. The roof had widespread damage, rafters were split, and the roof structure needed replacing after the tree fell during the storm, he said.

Schroeder said the Allstate desk reviewer never visited the site but based his reduction instructions solely on photographs and cost concerns.

After Schroeder declined to change his report, Allstate sent another adjuster to the stately home in Sandy Springs, Georgia. Cliff Millikan, who previously worked with Pilot and has mostly worked Allstate claims since 2016, said his estimates also were often reduced inappropriately by company reviewers.

He testified that he has seen a shift in Allstate’s claims handling in recent years.

“Since 2020, there have been changes in Allstate’s practices that undermine policyholders and erode trust in the insurance industry,” Millikan said.

Allstate has increasingly relied on unlicensed and inexperienced adjusters who do little more than take photos of damaged properties, added Millikan.

After Allstate’s corporate reviewers look at the photographs, wholesale changes are made to damage estimates, he noted.

“There’s no transparency,” Millikan said. “This confuses the policyholder. They’ve never had any interaction with the reviewer.” Allstate has essentially stripped qualified field adjusters of their authority to decide what damage should be considered storm-related, he said.

Millikan also testified that when adjusters resist Allstate’s instructions to reduce claims amounts, they get reassigned to another job or are avoided by the carrier.

Fiota said Allstate does not retaliate, and the company does not not frequently change field adjusters’ estimates. Schroeder, for example, had turned in 15 claims inspection reports after Helene, none of which were reviewed or altered by corporate staff.

The adjusters’ assertions echo statements made in recent years by several independent adjusters who worked hurricane claims in Florida and Louisiana. They have said that a number of insurance companies have frequently altered their reports in ways that made it appear that the field adjusters had drastically reduced their own estimates.

An Allstate spokesperson declined to comment on the hearings or Hawley’s questioning. Neil Alldredge, president and CEO of the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, said in a statement: “American insurers put customers first every day, providing guidance and timely payments when they’re needed most.”

***

Meanwhile, in another meeting room in Washington, a group of Democratic senators simultaneously held a separate hearing on the impact that climate change is having on property insurance premiums and the economy. Josh Levy, mayor of Hollywood, Florida, said climate change is adding stress to “Florida’s broken insurance market.”

Soaring premiums and nonrenewals for relatively young roofs are pushing insureds to the brink, he said. Legislative changes in 2022, designed to reduce excessive levels of claims lawsuits, have not yet produced broad-based rate relief, Levy said, contrary to Florida regulators’ reports that indicate that several carriers have offered minor rate decreases and that multiple new insurers have entered the market.

He called for more government intervention, including reinsurance and catastrophe backstop programs, more regulator oversight and incentives to spur more competition in the property insurance market.

Top photo: Sen. Josh Hawley (center), chairman of the Disaster Management Subcommittee of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, with New Jersey Sen. Andy Kim. Courtesy hawley.senate.gov

Topics Homeowners Politics