Despite Katrina lessons, Congress keeps extending flood insurance

By | January 8, 2007

The federal flood insurance program may be going broke after incurring $20 billion in debt from recent storms like Hurricane Katrina. But that hasn’t stopped politicians from trying to extend the taxpayer-subsidized coverage for some of the riskiest — and potentially most valuable — properties in the country.

For all it didn’t accomplish last year, Congress passed two bills carving out exceptions to a law passed years ago to phase out federal spending that might encourage development in environmentally sensitive and disaster-prone areas. One of the bills benefited Jekyll Island, a vacation spot off Georgia’s coast that is poised for redevelopment, while the other helped a mostly undeveloped 10-lot subdivision on Florida’s Gulf Coast.

A handful of similar proposals are pending. And after seeing the success of the Georgia and Florida bills this year, property owners in Alabama, Texas and elsewhere are lobbying for their own continued coverage.

“You only have to look at 300 miles of Katrina and Rita wasteland to see that bankrolling federal flood insurance in high-risk areas is just asking the American taxpayer to flush money down the toilet,” said Oliver Houck, director of the environmental law program at Tulane University in New Orleans. “If people want to build out there, that’s one thing. But to build out there with federal support is insane.”

The debate involves a Reagan-era environmental law called the Coastal Barrier Resources Act that was hailed as a free-market approach to conservation. Instead of restricting where private landowners could build, the law, nicknamed COBRA, mandated that the government would not subsidize such construction, whether through flood insurance, roads or otherwise.

However, as people flock to the coasts, Congress has repeatedly chipped away at the covered territory. Often responding to wealthy property owners who argue they were mistakenly included, lawmakers have redrawn COBRA maps more than 40 times in the past 15 years, according to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which oversees the maps.

At least four other bills stalled last year, and Fish and Wildlife officials say they have received more than 20 other requests for changes.

Even critics concede that mapping corrections are sometimes warranted and that the two exemptions approved last year are hardly a blip in the federal flood portfolio, which carries 5.4 million policies and recently eclipsed $1 trillion in coverage.

But they say Congress’ continued willingness to extend coverage is alarming, particularly in the hindsight of Katrina.

“The underlying principle is that every time COBRA runs up against individual interests, it’s always COBRA that loses,” said Steve Ellis, vice president of the watchdog group Taxpayers for Common Sense. “These are clearly areas where there’s a lot of development pressure and COBRA’s having an impact in denying that.”

Despite anecdotes that private flood insurance is unavailable, industry officials say it is for sale, just without the government subsidies.

It’s those subsidies that have put the federal system in need of a taxpayer bailout. The program owes the Treasury $20 billion. It takes in just $2 billion a year in premiums. More than a third of that — nearly $720 million a year — is now eaten up by debt interest.

Congress has wrestled with reforming the system by raising premiums and placing new requirements on homeowners. But lawmakers adjourned again last year without acting.

Instead, the two COBRA bills, added hundreds of high-risk properties and paved the way for new construction on vulnerable land.

“In the galaxy of federal subsidies, I don’t think there’s one that is so pointedly subsidizing wealthy people,” Houck said. “What happened to getting the government out of the hair of the private economy and letting the market work?”

Copyright 2007 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

From This Issue

Insurance Journal West January 8, 2007
January 8, 2007
Insurance Journal West Magazine

Contractors/Subcontractors; Employment Practices Liability Insurance; 2007 Meetings & Conventions Directory