Company Name 2004* 2005**
12/31/2004 6/30/2005
State Farm Mutual Auto Insurance Co. 964,544 159,665
St Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co. 654,788 46,260
Zurich American Insurance Co. 630,760 170,012
Auto-Owners Insurance Co. 552,943 92,361
Travelers Property Casualty Co. 543,845 132,852
Great West Casualty Co. 533,191 117,817
Lincoln General Insurance Co. 496,299 109,301
Cincinnati Insurance Co. 461,797 81,873
Universal Underwriters Insurance Co. 413,272 61,192
Progressive Casualty Insurance Co. 400,196 92,005
American Home Assurance Co. 382,939 NA
Empire Fire & Marine Insurance Co. 347,867 74,101
Canal Insurance Co. 338,708 70,893
Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance 320,562 74,355
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. 307,420 72,294
Sentry Select Insurance Co. 305,837 61,196
Northland Insurance Co. 305,640 60,858
Continental Casualty Co. 295,867 77,094
Allstate Insurance Co. 289,650 55,263
Hartford Fire Insurance Co. 287,429 59,084
Erie Insurance Exchange 264,857 50,606
Federal Insurance Co. 264,479 43,927
Progressive Northern Insurance Co. 258,796 56,771
American Transit Insurance Co. 257,665 57,266
Discover Prop & Cas Insurance Co. 254,546 48,420
TOTAL 10,133,897 1,925,466
* Top 25 based on 12/31/2004 Commercial Auto Liability and Physical Damage Direct Premium Written.
** Top 25 based on 6/30/2005 Commercial Auto Liability Direct Premium Written.
Developed by Demotech Inc., Columbus, Ohio, from Thomson Financial Insurance Solutions data.
Inquiries or requests for additional information should be directed to Barry J. Koestler II, Senior Financial Analyst, at (614) 761-8602 or bkoestler@demotech.com.
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.
North Carolina Adjuster and Son Charged With Embezzlement in Roof Jobs 
Former Congressman Charged After Collision with State Trooper in Florida 
Investment Funds File New Suits Over Lighthouse Insurance Collapse in 2022 
Progressive Gains as Drivers Shop Around for Auto Insurance—Again From This Issue
