The former chief executive of Brazilian iron ore miner Vale received an anonymous email weeks before the deadly collapse of a tailings dam at Brumadinho in January 2019 warning about “dams at their limit,” according to the findings of an exhaustive congressional report on the disaster.
Rather than seeking to investigate the allegation in the email, also addressed to other senior executives, Vale’s then-Chief Executive Officer Fabio Schvartsman directed other employees to try to identify the email’s author, according to the 625-page report.
The congressional investigative committee report, written by leftist congressman Rogerio Correia and released last week after five months of hearings, cited the email episode as evidence that Vale’s senior management, including Schvartsman, was aware ahead of the dam collapse – which killed more than 250 people – that there were safety issues with the facility used to store mining waste.
The congressional report was one of a series of investigations conducted in the wake of the Brumadinho disaster. Like an earlier Senate probe, the report from the Brazilian lower house suggested the indictment of various Vale executives, including Schvartsman, for homicide.
The former CEO “had full knowledge of the necessity of adopting urgent measures to increase the security of the dams in the priority area,” the report’s authors wrote.
Schvartsman was removed from the CEO job in early March at the urging of prosecutors who said in a letter to the board that his and other top Vale executives’ continued presence at the company posed “immeasurable risks to society.”
A Brazilian prosecutor told Reuters in September that the criminal probe into Vale’s actions related to the dam collapse was close to completion.
When Schvartsman was shown the anonymous email, he “took offense at the message’s content and asked that the sender be identified,” the report said, quoting the deposition of Alexandre de Aquino Pereira, Vale’s ethics and conduct general manager.
The claims about the anonymous email and Schvartsman’s demand that the sender be identified were first reported by the Wall Street Journal.
A lawyer for Schvartsman from the firm of Bottini & Tamasauskas did not immediately reply to a request for comment.
Vale’s Alexandre de Aquino Pereira was not immediately available for comment when contacted outside normal business hours.
A Vale spokeswoman said the email mentioned in the congressional report had been analyzed by the company’s ombudsman at the time and he had determined that its mention of “dams at their limit” was presented “generically and without evidence.”
The term “was understood as a reference to the limit of regulatory capacity of the dams, which was already being addressed by the company by, for example, expanding ‘dry processing’ operations,” she said.
Other complaints in the email focusing on a lack of investment in the company’s facilities were seen as groundless given that the company had boosted its spending on maintenance operations “significantly” in 2017 and 2018, she said.
(Reporting by Christian Plumb; Editing by Kenneth Maxwell)
Photograph: In this Jan. 28, 2019 file photo, firefighters search for victims of the Vale dam collapse in Brumadinho, Brazil. The Jan. 25 breach of the dam, owned and operated by Vale SA, unleashed tons of mud over a wide area in Brumadinho. Photo credit: AP Photo/Leo Correa.
- Brazil Police Accuse Mining Firm Vale, Auditor of Fraud Related to Deadly Dam Collapse
- Mining Firm Vale Must Fix All Damages from Deadly Dam Collapse: Brazil Court
- Vale’s Gongo Soco Mine Tailings Dam Faces 10%-15% Risk of Collapse: Brazil Official
- Brazil’s Vale Warns Another Mine Tailings Dam at Risk of Collapse
- Brazil’s Vale to Invest $2.5B in Technology to Prevent Mining Dam Disasters: Reuters
- Brazil Mining Giant Vale Warns Another Tailings Dam Could Collapse
- Brazil’s Backlash over Vale Dam Disaster Deepens with Mine Closure, Frozen Funds
- Brazil Miner Vale Fired Inspection Firm for Refusing to Certify Dam’s Safety: Prosecutors
- Vale CEO and Several Senior Execs Resign After Deadly Brazil Dam Disaster
- Brazil Probe into Possible Safety Cover-up by Vale Could Lead to Massive Fine
- Brazil Senate Passes Dam Safety Bill After Vale Disaster; Insurance Provision Eyed
- Brazil Tailings Dam Disaster Pushes Mining CEOs to Make Safety Changes
- Brazil Prosecutors Seek Arrest of Vale Executive after Tailings Dam Disaster
- Vale’s Senior Management Unaware of Dam Risk Report, Says CFO
- Brazil Miner Vale Knew Its Tailings Dam Had Higher Risk of Collapse: Reuters
- Brazil’s Burst Dam Disasters Blamed on Cheap Storage of Mining Waste
- Brazil Dam Disaster Could Delay Settlement for 2015’s Samarco Mine Disaster
- Brazil Weighs Management Overhaul at Vale After Mine Disaster; Death Toll Rises
- Allianz Has Reinsurance Exposure to Vale Dam Disaster: Sources
- Collapsed Brazil Mining Dam Kills at Least 58, in Echoes of 2015 Disaster
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.