It might be the most talked-about Christmas party at the Michigan Supreme Court.
The justices on Friday let stand an appeals court decision and said a jury should decide whether an Oakland County couple is liable for a woman’s injuries when she stepped into a dark room during a 2013 party.
Susan Blackwell was injured when she missed an 8-inch step in the mudroom at the home of Dean and Debra Franchi.
The resulting case has made two trips to the Supreme Court. The court heard arguments at a different stage in 2018.
Blackwell “was injured when she entered a dark room and fell because she was surprised by an 8-inch step down. … Whether the defendants should have warned her about it — whether they breached their duty — is a question” for jurors, Chief Justice Bridget McCormack said.
Justice Stephen Markman disagreed. He said other lawsuits will be “lying in wait.”
“On what principled grounds should a host expect a guest to act with greater judgment in a wide realm of similarly looming household mishaps: sink and shower faucets configured to dispense hot water; ovens and stoves that heat up; throw rugs that are unstable; chairs capable of tipping over?” Markman said.
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.
AIG’s Zaffino to Step Down as CEO as Aon’s Andersen Steps In 
Litigation Funding, Other New Laws in SE States Could Impact Liability Insurance 
High-Net-Worth Risk Appetite Drops as Some Regions Show Stabilization 
Relief But Questions on Agents’ Duties to Insureds After Florida Court Ruling 
