Willis Capital Market Report Finds Decline in ILS Issues as Growth Stabilizes

According to the latest ILS report from Willis Capital Markets & Advisory (WCMA), part of Willis Group Holdings plc, “$650 million of non-life Rule 144A catastrophe bond capacity was issued across three transactions in the third quarter of 2015, taking total market issuance for the first nine months of 2015 to $4.8 billion,” a 19 percent decline, compared to the same period in 2014.”

However, the report also notes that “total ILS assets under management continue to grow, albeit at a slower rate than the record breaking pace of recent years.”

Bill Dubinsky, Head of ILS at WCMA, explained: “The insurance-linked securities market is at an inflection point. Despite the continued downward pressure on reinsurance rates, investor appetite remains strong and we’ve seen net new capital come into the re/insurance arena during 2015.

“However, the proportion of Rule 144A catastrophe bonds issued compared to other forms of ILS is down as investors have shifted towards more illiquid products, such as private cat bonds and collateralized reinsurance.”

WCMA said the “report questions if this development signals a structural shift or just a ‘head fake.”‘

“There are arguments for and against,” Dubinsky said. “To an extent, the shift illustrates increased investor confidence as the market matures. Over time, investors have become more comfortable and knowledgeable about reinsurance risk and are now more receptive to move into more illiquid products with greater confidence. However, this shift is also a sign of more immediate changes within the industry as the recent flurry of M&A activity, coupled with changing program design, has put reinsurance needs in a state of flux.

“Whether or not the shift away from 144A catastrophe bonds is permanent or temporary, competitive tension continues to provide ceding companies and investors with ample product choice, both to cede risk and invest,” he concluded.

The report said also noted that Bermuda has become the “the predominant domicile for new ILS vehicles: in 2011, Bermuda represented 18 percent of the market; it now represents 67 percent.”

Dubinsky described this as a “structural change;” adding that “since the start of the market the Cayman Islands has been the leading domicile for cat bonds. Roughly 90 percent of all cat bonds issued since the mid-1990s to 2012 were domiciled in Cayman.

“However, despite Cayman’s new Insurance Law in 2013, Bermuda is emerging as the preferred domicile for new ILS vehicles. We wait and see how this will change with the UK Treasury’s stated intention to make London a primary center for the issuance of cat bonds and other ILS products as well as the initiatives in other jurisdictions.”

The full report is available.

Source: Willis Capital Markets & Advisory (WCMA)

Topics Trends Catastrophe Reinsurance