• MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
Insurance Journal - Property Casualty Industry News

Featured Stories

  • Top Insurance M&As of 2020
  • FEMA Buys Flood Reinsurance
  • News
  • Markets

Current Magazine

current magazine
  • Read Online
  • Subscribe
  • Front Page
    • National
    • International
    • Most Popular
    • Magazine
    • Forums
    • Blogs
    • Videos/Podcasts
    • Newsletters
  • News
    • Most Popular
    • National
    • International
    • East
    • Midwest
    • South Central
    • Southeast
    • West
  • Magazines
    • East
    • Midwest
    • South Central
    • Southeast
    • West
    • Subscribe
  • Research
  • Directories
  • Jobs
  • Features
    • Events
    • Forums
    • Insurance Twitter
    • Market Directories
    • Quotes
    • Polls
    • Rankings & Awards
  • Subscribe

Uber Driver Case Tests ‘Sharing Economy’ Business Model

By Eric Newcomer and Joel Rosenblatt | August 4, 2015
Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
Email to a friend Facebook Tweet LinkedIn Print Article
  • Article
  • 0 Comments

The most serious challenge to Uber Technologies Inc.’s “Be your own Boss” business model might also present an early test to the wider sharing economy as well as undermine its own $50 billion valuation.

The immediate battle comes Thursday in San Francisco, where Uber is seen as having a difficult task in persuading U.S. District Judge Edward M. Chen to block a lawsuit seeking to reimburse 160,000 California drivers for mileage and tips from proceeding as a class action.

Chen’s decision hinges on the broader issue of whether Uber drivers are independent contractors, as the company claims, or employees entitled to unemployment and workers’ compensation as well as the right to unionize. The issue is already fodder for the 2016 presidential campaign, with Democrat Hillary Clinton drawing fire from Republican rivals after saying the sharing economy, though promising, raises “hard questions about workplace protections.”

Besides crimping Uber’s “drive whenever you have time” motto, a ruling treating drivers as employees, if upheld on appeal, would dampen profits. It would also raise the same specter for other companies operating in the “sharing,” “gig” or “on-demand” economy, which pair customers with products through apps and typically avoid the costs of traditional employment. The Uber lawsuit before Chen, the most advanced of similar cases, argues the model violates labor laws.

‘Legal Uncertainty’

The case is significant for firms that farm out work to others in exchange for a share of the revenue they generate, said Christopher Sagers, a Cleveland State University law professor. “I think that a plaintiff win would put them in some legal uncertainty,” he said.

Two Uber investors who asked not to be identified said the company could survive any decision requiring it to treat drivers as employees.

Uber’s value might drop because it’s based partly on the arrangements with drivers. Treating them as employees would add to costs and probably shrink profit.

Classifying drivers as employees would result in higher prices, and fewer Uber drivers overall who must work longer hours, said Arun Sundararajan, a professor at New York University’s Stern School of Business. The higher costs would be passed on to consumers, with reductions in drivers’ income and Uber’s cut of their fares, he said.

The effect on Uber’s global revenue would likely be small, Sundararajan said. “I think the real risk is that if they lose in California, other states will follow,” he said.

Lyft, Homejoy

Chen has already ruled that a jury will decide the case if it goes to trial. Other sharing-economy companies are paying attention to Uber’s fight.

Shannon Liss-Riordan, the lawyer representing the drivers, has filed similar cases against companies including Uber competitor Lyft Inc., as well as sharing-economy ventures Caviar Inc., Postmates Inc. and Homejoy Inc., an on-demand house cleaning company that ended operations on Friday.

Homejoy Chief Executive Officer Adora Cheung said her company buckled under the weight of the litigation threat.

Uber’s spread in the U.S. and around the world has been pockmarked with lawsuits and prosecutions over accidents and alleged crimes by drivers including rape. The company is also subject to government probes of whether it violates labor laws and local regulations designed largely for taxi service.

The drivers’ case may succeed — or not — based on whether it proceeds as group suit. Stanford Law School Professor William Gould called it a “good candidate” for a class action, which increases defendants’ potential costs and gives plaintiffs leverage to negotiate a deal.

Independence, Flexibility

Uber stresses the independence and flexibility drivers enjoy — they can work whenever and as often as they like. It claims to rely on as many as 17 different licensing agreements for drivers.

Some of the licensing agreements describe a “mutual right to terminate,” which Uber argues is typical of independent contractor relationships. Others give Uber the right to terminate for specific misconduct and require a minimum amount of notice, according to the company.

Chen would be required to make too many “individualized inquiries” assessing each driver’s understanding of Uber’s policies to make a group lawsuit viable, the company argued.

‘Singular’ Point

Uber’s ability to terminate drivers at will, or for any reason and without warning, is of “singular importance,” the plaintiffs argue in a court filing. That policy proves Uber’s control, which means the drivers qualify as employees, according to the filing.

For Uber, the road ahead isn’t likely to get easier, according to Sagers and Gould.

FedEx Corp. lost an appeal in a case brought by its drivers and agreed to a $228 million settlement. That deal is scheduled to be considered by Chen Thursday, just before Uber’s hearing.

The FedEx case works in Uber’s favor, said Theodore Boutrous, one of the ride-share company’s lawyers.

“FedEx delivery drivers do not have anywhere near the flexibility or autonomy that drivers who use the Uber app have,” Boutrous said in an e-mail. “Uber has none of these types of rigid controls over drivers; indeed, most drivers value Uber precisely because they are not subject to this type of inflexible arrangement.”

The case is O’Connor v. Uber Technologies.

Related:

  • Will Uber Employee Status Ruling in California Impact Its Business Model?
  • New Worker Classification Needed for Sharing Economy, Uber Drivers
  • Commission Rules Uber Drivers Employees, Not Contractors
  • Labor Department’s 6-Part Test for Classifying Employees, Independent Contractors
  • Uber Expected to Ride Out Employee Ruling, Maintain High Valuation
  • NYC Taxi Regulator Sides With Uber in Employee vs. Contractor Debate

Copyright 2021 Bloomberg.

Was this article valuable?

Thank you! Please tell us what we can do to improve this article.

Thank you! % of people found this article valuable. Please tell us what you liked about it.

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Florida’s Property Insurance Market Is ‘Spiraling Towards Collapse’ Due to Litigation: Report
American Family Insurance to Acquire Small Business Insurtech Bold Penguin
How Climate Change May Affect Hurricane Risk and Losses: AIR, Brookings, AXIS
Insurance Agency M&A Deals Surged 20% in Year of Pandemic: OPTIS

Interested in Lawsuits?

Get automatic alerts for this topic.

Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
Email to a friend Facebook Tweet LinkedIn Print Article
  • Categories: National NewsTopics: be your own boss business model, corporate sharing economy, drive whenever you have time, employer control over employees, gig economy, Homejoy, individual sharing economy, labor laws and ridesharing, O’Connor v. Uber Technologies, on-demand economy, on-demand house cleaning company, sharing economy, sharing economy workers' compensation, Uber employees, uber independent contractors, Uber San Francisco, unions and sharing economy
  • Have a hot lead? Email us at newsdesk@insurancejournal.com

Advertisers

Add a CommentSee All Comments (0)Add a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

More News
‘Totally Destroyed’ Indonesia Jet in Java Sea Makes Search Almost Impossible
United Airlines CEO Urges Employers to Mandate COVID-19 Vaccines
Volkswagen Talks Damages Claims Against Chip Suppliers Over shortages
California Construction Worker Charged with Workers’ Comp Fraud
More News Features

Read This Next

  • Uber Driver Case Tests ‘Sharing Economy’ Business Model
  • Brazil Miner Vale, State Authorities Narrow Differences in Disaster Settlement: Source
  • Tennessee Insurance Dept. Makes Multiple Leadership Changes
  • 'Totally Destroyed' Indonesia Jet in Java Sea Makes Search Almost Impossible
  • Investors Suing Bayer Blame Drop in Stock on Buying Monsanto, Roundup

Insurance Jobs

  • Middle Market Broker - Chicago, IL
  • Catastrophe Field Property Adjuster – Fort Lauderdale - Fort Lauderdale, FL
  • Auto Theft Adjuster - Northbrook, IL
  • Auto GHRN Administrator - Anniston, AL
  • Virtual Triage Total Loss Adjuster - Anniston, AL
MyNewMarkets
  • Ongoing Pandemic Brings Workforce, Risk, Policy Challenges for Insurers
  • Workers' Comp Expansion for COVID-19 Led to Narrow Benefit in 6 States
  • Lloyd's Perspective on the U.S. Property Insurance Environment
  • Expect Shift in Workers' Comp Profitability in 2021: Fitch
  • Frequency of Cyber Events Targeting Businesses Increasing: Travelers
Claims Journal
  • Biden Blocking Keystone Threatens to End Mega Pipelines Era
  • U.S. Business Starts Enjoyed Their Best Year Ever Amid Covid-19
  • Deal Offers More Banking Services for California Pot Firms
  • California Winds Easing After Sparking Fires, Power Outages
  • Alaska Village Loses Running Water After Fire Destroys Plant
Academy of Insurance education
  • January 21 Commercial Property Master Class - COPE (Construction)
  • January 26 Top Ten Flood Topics
  • January 28 The Future of Claims and Technology
  • February 2 Business Continuity and Extra Expense

Insurance News

  • News by Region
  • News by Topic
  • Yesterday

Site Search

Features

  • Insurance Markets Directory
  • Forums
  • A.M. Best Company Ratings
  • Industry Events
  • Agencies For Sale
  • Newswire
  • Insurance Jobs
  • Rankings & Awards

Connect with us

  • Email Newsletters
  • Magazine Subscriptions
  • For Your Website
  • RSS Feeds
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Do Not Sell My Info

Insurance Journal

  • Submit News
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Reprints
  • Link to Us
  • Contact Us

Wells Media Group Network

  • Insurance Journal
  • MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
© 2021 by Wells Media Group, Inc. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Site Map

We have updated our privacy policy to be more clear and meet the new requirements of the GDPR. By continuing to use our site, you accept our revised Privacy Policy.