Obama Inauguration May Raise Insurance, Legal Issues for Enterprising Homeowners

By | December 2, 2008

The days leading up to the inauguration of Barack Obama could be an economic windfall for residential property owners in and around D.C.

Washington Post staff writer David Nakamura reports that droves of people are looking for temporary housing as they make plans to witness presidential history next January and nearly as many home and condominium owners are making space in their homes for these travelers – at a price.

Profit and the motivation to earn a profit is the American way, but what insurance and legal issues does this temporary housing boom create for the property owner? Turns out, not much in regards to insurance coverage; however the legal liability issue is a bit stickier.

Homeowners’ policy forms specifically exclude coverage for loss resulting from the theft of personal property located in areas of the residence rented to others. Owners who rent the entire residence will have no insurance protection for loss caused by theft;’ those who rent out a room or a section of a house (i.e. the basement) will lose coverage for theft of property in that area only.

But what about the ‘Landlord’s Furnishings’ additional coverage– doesn’t that extend $2,500 for loss caused by theft? Yes it does, but only if the area is usually (customarily, in the normal course of ownership, etc.) held for rental; one-time or “special occasion” rentals do not qualify for this extension of coverage.

Other than the theft exclusion, there is no real insurance coverage issue. The real exposure for the homeowner is one of legal liability.

Property owners owe a specific duty of care to every person who enters their property; the level of care is based on the classification of the individual on the property (see “Duties Owed to Visitors“). These short-term, contractual relationships transform these individuals into “invitees.” Invitees are owed the greatest duty of care.

To match the duty of care owed to an invitee (and have a defense against legal liability), the property owner is charged with: 1) thoroughly inspecting the property to discover all hazards; 2) correcting or minimizing all known and discovered hazards; and 3) warning the invitee of dangers, those that may be considered obvious and those that are not obvious or even hidden (don’t turn on that light, it will shock you).

Closing the theft exclusion gap can be accomplished with Insurance Services Office’s (ISO’s) HO 05 41 – Extended Theft Coverage for Residence Premises Rented to Others; satisfying the duty of care owed to the “invitee” requires personal effort and potentially some personal expense.

About Christopher J. Boggs

Boggs is the vice president for education for Insurance Journal’s Academy of Insurance, responsible for managing all aspects of the Academy from researching, writing and presenting his own classes to managing a group of instructors to developing and managing the education schedule. Since joining the insurance industry in 1990, Boggs has authored more than 300 insurance and risk management-related articles including six e-books. Email: cboggs@ijacademy.com. Website: http://www.ijacademy.com/. More from Christopher J. Boggs
Get Insurance Journal Every Day

Latest Comments

  • January 6, 2009 at 10:15 am
    RS says:
    Really, the "liberal media" didn't cover it? Then why is it still on the CBS News website? (http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/07/05/world/main4235028.shtml). And no one ever... read more
  • December 3, 2008 at 1:38 am
    Ralph says:
    really? I didn't know we removed yellow cake uranium from Iraq. I heard it was just a suicide bomber that blew up Iraq's only Twinkie factory, maybe that was the yellow cake y... read more
  • December 3, 2008 at 1:20 am
    Bill Ayers says:
    I can't believe that the author of the article spends so much text on the topic of theft. It's as if he suspects that attendees might be likely to steal from the homes they a... read more
See all comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


More News
More News Features