1 Brickstreet Mutual Insurance Co. WV 765,963
2 Texas Mutual Insurance Co. TX 743,095
3 Old American Cty Mutual Fire Insurance Co. TX 491,641
4 SAIF Corp. OR 449,794
5 Universal Property & Casualty Insurance FL 371,755
6 Physicians Reciprocal Insurers NY 336,605
7 Louisiana Workers Compensation Corp. LA 261,869
8 American Transit Insurance Co. NY 183,325
9 Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. of AR Inc. AR 180,597
10 Nuclear Electric Insurance Ltd. DE 178,522
11 Kentucky Employers Mutual Insurance KY 176,129
12 American Steamship Owners Mutual Prot. NY 175,967
13 Mutual Insurance Co. of AZ AZ 171,574
14 Proformance Insurance Co. NJ 171,069
15 United Property & Casualty Insurance Co. FL 158,162
16 Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. IN 150,304
17 St. Johns Insurance Co. Inc. FL 146,543
18 Pioneer State Mutual Insurance Co. MI 143,916
19 MO Employers Mutual Insurance Co. MO 143,890
20 Rural Mutual Insurance Co. WI 137,725
21 Gulfstream Property & Casualty Insurance Co. FL 134,397
22 Louisiana Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. LA 126,706
23 Aequicap Insurance Co. FL 126,097
24 Florida Peninsula Insurance Co. FL 114,707
25 COPIC Insurance Co. CO 112,211
26 Sunshine State Insurance Co. FL 105,011
27 Compwest Insurance Co. CA 100,024
28 Florida Family Mutual Insurance Co. FL 95,795
29 First Protective Insurance Co. FL 94,174
30 MDadvantage Insurance Co. of NJ NJ 92,545
31 Hawaii Employers Mutual Insurance Co. HI 87,442
32 Underwriters at Lloyd’s London IL 86,924
33 New York Schools Insurance Reciprocal NY 83,938
34 Hereford Insurance Co. NY 81,757
35 Bear River Mutual Insurance Co. UT 78,764
36 Physicians Liability Insurance Co. OK 76,984
37 Countrywide Insurance Co. NY 76,550
38 Underwriters at Lloyd’s KY 73,437
39 Associated Industries Insurance Co. Inc. FL 72,944
40 Hospitals Insurance Co. Inc. NY 68,861
41 Majestic Insurance Co. CA 66,585
42 American Physicians Insurance Exchange TX 65,286
43 American Access Casualty Co. IL 64,197
44 Catholic Relief Insurance Co. of America NE 62,720
45 Colorado Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. CO 61,685
46 West Virginia Physicians Mutual Insurance Co. WV 57,583
47 Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Co. WI 57,514
48 Louisiana Medical Mutual Insurance Co. LA 56,862
49 Adirondack Insurance Exchange NY 54,566
50 Crusader Insurance Co. CA 51,914
51 Lawyers Mutual Insurance Co. CA 51,678
52 Connecticut Medical Insurance Co. CT 50,092
53 Coral Insurance Co. FL 49,831
54 New York Municipal Insurance Reciprocal NY 49,440
55 Fremont Insurance Co. MI 48,869
56 Sterling Insurance Co. NY 48,728
57 Erie & Niagra Insurance Assoc. NY 48,203
58 Capitol Preferred Insurance Co. FL 48,082
59 Auto Club South Insurance Co. FL 46,884
60 New Jersey Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange NJ 43,782
61 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Salem Cty. NJ 43,104
62 Florida Hospitality Mutual Insurance FL 42,701
63 Missouri Physicians Mutual MO 41,271
64 Kansas Medical Mutual Insurance Co. KS 41,173
65 Dryden Mutual Insurance Co. NY 39,654
66 Stonetrust Commercial Insurance Co. LA 38,567
67 First Home Insurance Co. FL 38,473
68 State-Wide Insurance Co. NY 37,897
69 Southeastern US Captive Insurance Inc. GA 36,539
70 Security Mutual Insurance Co. NY 36,080
71 IFA Insurance Co. NJ 36,052
72 Alabama Municipal Insurance Corp. AL 35,721
73 Southern Fidelity Insurance Co. Inc. FL 33,038
74 Madison Mutual Insurance Co. IL 32,680
75 Southern Oak Insurance Co. FL 31,919
76 Ram Mutual Insurance Co. MN 31,750
77 Farmers Insurance Co. of Flemington NJ 31,475
78 Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. ND 31,465
79 Pennsylvania Healthcare Providers Insurance PA 30,238
80 Seaworthy Insurance Co. MD 30,207
81 Nevada Mutual Insurance Co. Inc. NV 30,161
82 Granada Insurance Co. FL 29,745
83 Suretec Insurance Co. TX 28,636
84 Academic Health Professionals Insurance NY 28,516
85 Rider Insurance Co. NJ 28,457
86 Care West Insurance Co. CA 28,062
87 Texas Lawyers Insurance Exchange TX 27,171
88 Discovery Insurance Co. NC 27,067
89 American Traditions Insurance Co. FL 24,531
90 Businessfirst Insurance Co. FL 23,918
91 Unique Insurance Co. IL 23,860
92 German Mutual Insurance Co. OH 23,747
93 Tri-State Consumer Insurance Co. NY 23,433
94 Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. MT 23,100
95 Global Liberty Insurance Co. of NY NY 22,990
96 Advocate MD Insurance of the SW Inc. TX 21,780
97 Frederick Mutual Insurance Co. MD 21,766
98 Hillcrest Insurance Co. FL 21,437
99 Millville Mutual Insurance Co. PA 21,391
100 Professional Casualty Association PA 21,390
101 Bremen Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. KS 21,221
102 Edison Insurance Co. FL 20,695
103 Conventus Inter Insurance Exchange NJ 20,647
104 Commercial Mutual Insurance Co. NY 20,645
105 Frank Winston Crum Insurance Inc. FL 20,160
106 The USA Insurance Co. MS 19,825
107 Farmers Mech Mutual Fire Insurance of WV WV 19,786
108 Michigan Professional Insurance Exchange MI 19,719
109 Business Alliance Insurance Co. CA 19,150
110 Star Casualty Insurance Co. FL 18,814
111 Alliance United Insurance Co. CA 18,718
112 Southern Eagle Insurance Co. FL 18,603
113 Harbor Insurance Co. OK 18,408
114 Springfield Insurance Co. Inc. CA 18,143
115 Primero Insurance Co. NV 18,018
116 North Carolina Grange Mutual Insurance Co. NC 17,993
117 Wayne Mutual Insurance Co. OH 17,847
118 Security First Insurance Co. FL 17,800
119 Delta Lloyds Insurance Co. of Houston TX 17,713
120 Wellington Insurance Co. TX 17,329
121 Fiduciary Insurance Co. of America NY 17,276
122 Otsego Mutual Fire Insurance Co. NY 16,983
123 New Jersey Physicians United Reciprocal Exchange NJ 16,708
124 IL State Bar Assoc. Mutual Insurance Co. IL 16,497
125 ID Counties Risk Management Program Undw. ID 16,343
126 Marysville Mutual Insurance Co. KS 16,054
127 Eveready Insurance Co. NY 15,983
128 League of WI Municipalities Mutual Insurance WI 15,898
129 Louisiana Retailers Mutual Insurance LA 15,888
130 Lion Insurance Co. FL 15,880
131 Fire Districts of NY Mutual Insurance Co. Inc. NY 15,859
132 Housing & Redevelopment Insurance Exchange PA 15,791
133 Capacity Insurance Co. FL 15,451
134 Windhaven Insurance Co. FL 15,114
135 Constitutional Casualty Co. IL 14,905
136 Seven Seas Insurance Co. Inc. FL 14,699
137 Lebanon Mutual Insurance Co. PA 14,583
138 Millennium Insurance Co. PA 14,580
139 Upland Mutual Insurance Inc. KS 14,293
140 American Freedom Insurance Co. IL 14,055
141 Royal Palm Insurance Co. FL 13,957
142 Baldwin Mutual Insurance Co. AL 13,949
143 Consumer First Insurance Co. NJ 13,886
144 Florida Lawyers Mutual Insurance Co. FL 13,814
145 OHA Insurance Solutions OH 13,474
146 Farmers Fire Insurance Co. PA 13,438
147 Physicians Preferred Insurance Reciprocal FL 13,336
148 Medical Alliance Insurance Co. IL 13,190
149 Waco Fire & Casualty Insurance Co. GA 12,940
150 WVA Insurance Co. WV 12,719
151 American Underwriters Insurance Co. AR 12,640
152 Pennsylvania Physicians Reciprocal Insurance PA 12,232
153 Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Co. WI 12,073
154 NHRMA Mutual Insurance Co. IL 12,054
155 National Automotive Insurance LA 11,911
156 Surety Co. of the Pacific CA 11,805
157 Midstate Mutual Insurance Co. NY 11,772
158 Mennonite Mutual Insurance Co. OH 11,672
159 Texas Hospital Insurance Exchange TX 11,610
160 Allegany Cooperative Insurance Co. NY 11,566
161 Great Lakes Casualty Insurance Co. MI 11,265
162 Employers Security Insurance Co. IN 10,970
163 Wayne Cooperative Insurance Co. NY 10,919
164 Florida Healthcare Providers Insurance Exchange FL 10,778
165 Farm Credit Sys Assoc. Captive Insurance Co. CO 10,772
166 North Country Insurance Co. NY 10,720
167 Associated Mutual Insurance Co. NY 10,682
168 US Lloyd’s Insurance Co. TX 10,623
169 Peachtree Casualty Insurance Co. FL 10,581
170 Northern Mutual Insurance Co. MI 10,513
171 Physical Professional Ind Association MO 10,468
172 Spring Valley Mutual Insurance Co. MN 10,318
173 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Marble PA 10,064
174 Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance Co. Ltd. NY 10,040
175 School Boards Insurance Co. of PA Inc. PA 9,877
176 Sheboygan Falls Mutual Insurance Co. WI 9,721
177 Physicians Insurance Co. FL 9,688
178 Healthcare Underwriters Group of FL FL 9,361
179 AIMCO Mutual Insurance Co. NC 9,352
180 Pioneer General Insurance Co. CO 9,050
181 Sunz Insurance Co. FL 8,982
182 Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty Insurance Co. NY 8,948
183 Amfirst Insurance Co. MS 8,790
184 Battle Creek Mutual Insurance Co. NE 8,684
185 Chautauqua Patrons Insurance Assoc. NY 8,624
186 Colonial Cooperative Insurance Co. NY 8,618
187 Nazareth Mutual Insurance Co. PA 8,545
188 Accident Insurance Co. Inc. SC 8,368
189 Kansas Mutual Insurance Co. KS 8,353
190 Oklahoma Attorneys Mutual Insurance Co. OK 8,113
191 Alliance Mutual Insurance Co. NC 8,089
192 American Fellowship Mutual Insurance Co. MI 8,049
193 Cities & Villages Mutual Insurance Co. WI 7,956
194 Agent Alliance Insurance Co. NC 7,943
195 Positive Physicians Insurance Exchange PA 7,930
196 Capitol Insurance Co. PA 7,899
197 Healthcare Underwriters Group of KY KY 7,758
198 Dongbu Insurance Co. Ltd. HI 7,686
199 Long Island Insurance Co. NY 7,627
200 Merced Mutual Insurance Co. CA 7,481
201 Union Mutual Insurance Co. OK 7,363
202 Lawyers Mutual Insurance Co. of KY KY 7,162
203 Paramount Insurance Co. MD 7,133
204 Wisconsin American Mutual Insurance WI 7,062
205 Casualty Corp. of America OK 6,960
206 North Sea Insurance Co. NY 6,930
207 Health Care Insurance Reciprocal MN 6,903
208 Farmers Mutual of Tennessee TN 6,705
209 Fairmont Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. MN 6,694
210 Bell United Insurance Co. NV 6,650
211 First Jersey Casualty Insurance Co. Inc. NJ 6,547
212 Interstate Casualty Insurance Co. IL 6,463
213 Mid-Hudson Co-Operative Insurance Co. NY 6,447
214 Sterling Casualty Insurance Co. CA 6,394
215 Texas Builders Insurance Co. TX 6,291
216 McMillan Warner Mutual Insurance Co. WI 6,283
217 Healthcare Underwriters Group Mutual OH OH 6,182
218 Old Glory Insurance Co. TX 6,149
219 Northern Capital Insurance Co. FL 6,146
220 Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Co. AR 6,144
221 Reamstown Mutual Insurance Co. PA 6,137
222 Areca Insurance Exchange AK 6,134
223 Arizona Automobile Insurance Co. AZ 6,099
224 West Virginia National Auto Insurance Co. WV 5,932
225 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Okarche Ok OK 5,831
226 Callicoon Cooperative Insurance Co. NY 5,781
227 Interstate Auto Insurance Co. Inc. MD 5,765
228 Alaska Timber Insurance Exchange AK 5,750
229 Arrow Mutual Liability Insurance Co. MA 5,744
230 Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. (KS) KS 5,713
231 Halifax Mutual Insurance Co. NC 5,661
232 Ohio Bar Liability Insurance Co. OH 5,644
233 Commercial Alliance Insurance Co. TX 5,631
234 Retailers Mutual Insurance Co. MI 5,610
235 American Liberty Insurance Co. UT 5,576
236 Leatherstocking Coop Insurance Co. NY 5,515
237 CBIA Comp Services Inc. CT 5,430
238 Central Cooperative Insurance Co. NY 5,357
239 Kensington Insurance Co. NY 5,325
240 Oswego County Mutual Insurance Co. NY 5,307
241 Georgia Mutual Insurance Co. GA 5,269
242 Freedom Advantage Insurance Co. PA 5,201
243 Physicians Insurance Program Reciprocal Exchange PA 5,200
244 Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. (WV) WV 5,157
245 Manitowoc Mutual Insurance Co. WI 5,150
246 Quality Casualty Insurance Co. Inc. AL 5,120
247 California Mutual Insurance Co. CA 5,110
248 Maple Valley Mutual Insurance Co. WI 5,095
249 Farmers Home Mutual Fire Insurance Co. AR 5,085
250 First Mutual Insurance Co. NC 5,063
251 Community Mutual Insurance Co. NY 5,029
252 National Heritage Insurance Co. IL 4,862
253 Workers Compensation Exchange ID 4,852
254 Florida Doctors Insurance Co. FL 4,772
255 Genesee Patrons Coop Insurance Co. NY 4,771
256 Juniata Mutual Insurance Co. PA 4,651
257 Districts Mutual Insurance WI 4,632
258 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Mccandless PA 4,615
259 Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. (PA) PA 4,614
260 Missouri Doctors Mutual Insurance Co. MO 4,613
261 Preferred Auto Insurance Co. Inc. TN 4,566
262 Hartland Mutual Insurance Co. ND 4,478
263 WI Lawyers Mutual Insurance Co. WI 4,441
264 GA Timber Harvesters Mutual Captive GA 4,439
265 Farmers and Merch Mutual Fire Insurance Co. MI 4,435
266 Ontario Insurance Co. NY 4,434
267 Maya Assurance Co. NY 4,433
268 Bedford Grange Mutual Insurance Co. PA 4,420
269 Briar Creek Mutual Insurance Co. PA 4,369
270 National Home Warranty Inc. NV 4,361
271 Texas Medical Insurance Co. TX 4,338
272 Midrox Insurance Co. NY 4,298
273 Taxisure Exchange NJ 4,250
274 New Jersey Healthcare Providers Insurance NJ 4,245
275 Attorneys Insurance Mutual of Alabama Inc. AL 4,152
276 Health Care Mutual Captive Insurance Co. GA 4,120
277 Homesure Protection of CA Inc. CA 4,119
278 Integra Insurance Inc. MN 4,099
279 Whitecap Surety Co. MN 4,052
280 Madison Mutual Insurance Co. NY 4,034
281 Laundry Owners Mutual Liability Insurance Assn. PA 3,994
282 Tank Owners Mutual Insurance Co. TX 3,942
283 United Frontier Mutual Insurance Co. NY 3,857
284 Missouri Valley Mutual Insurance Co. SD 3,834
285 British American Insurance Co. TX 3,771
286 EZ Auto Inc. Co. UT 3,735
287 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Dug Hill MD 3,725
288 American Millennium Insurance Co. NJ 3,716
289 Gem State Insurance Co. ID 3,673
290 Fulmont Mutual Insurance Co. NY 3,658
291 First Indemnity of America Insurance Co. NJ 3,647
292 United Insurance Co. UT 3,625
293 Agents Mutual Insurance Co. AR 3,592
294 Springfield Fire & Casualty Co. IL 3,589
295 Maryland Healthcare Providers Insurance Exchange MD 3,572
296 Homeowners of America Insurance Co. TX 3,543
297 Friends Cove Mutual Insurance Co. PA 3,539
298 Austin Ind Lloyds Insurance Co. TX 3,504
299 Wisconsin Municipal Mutual Insurance Co. WI 3,479
300 Wilmington Insurance Co. DE 3,423
301 National Unity Insurance Co. TX 3,412
302 Safe Insurance Co. WV 3,409
303 GA Resaurant Mutual Captive Insurance Co. GA 3,253
304 Legal Mutual Liab Insurance Society of MD MD 3,230
305 Sheffield Insurance Co. TN 3,209
306 Drivers Insurance Co. NY 2,982
307 Nevada Direct Insurance Co. NV 2,978
308 Ethio American Insurance Co. GA 2,975
309 Hay Creek Mutual Insurance Co. MN 2,958
310 Little Black Mutual Insurance Co. WI 2,881
311 Petroleum Marketers Mutual Insurance Co. IA 2,774
312 Farmers & Mechanics Fire & Casualty Insurance WV 2,772
313 Sunderland Marine Mutual Co. Ltd. AK 2,755
314 Mutual Insurance Co. of Lehigh County PA 2,754
315 Carolina Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. NC 2,745
316 United Business Insurance Co. GA 2,712
317 Town & Country Mutual Insurance Co. AR 2,664
318 Greenville Casualty Insurance Co. Inc. SC 2,617
319 Transit Mutual Insurance Corp. of WI WI 2,607
320 Delaware Professional Insurance Co. DE 2,509
321 Mound Prairie Mutual Insurance Co. MN 2,338
322 Pan Handle Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. of WV WV 2,333
323 New York Transportation Insurance Corp. NY 2,259
324 Washington County Co-Operative Insurance NY 2,250
325 Hannahstown Mutual Insurance Co. PA 2,237
326 Northern Plains Insurance Co. SD 2,224
327 New Mexico Property & Casualty Co. NM 2,199
328 Ellington Mutual Insurance Co. WI 2,108
329 MLBA Mutual Insurance Co. MI 2,053
330 Mount Carroll Mutual Fire Insurance Co. IL 2,042
331 Galen Insurance Co. MO 2,038
332 Victore Insurance Co. OK 2,021
333 Gibraltar National Insurance Co. AR 2,002
334 Reliamax Surety Co. SD 1,984
335 Bloomfield Mutual Insurance Co. MN 1,960
336 Geneva Insurance Co. IN 1,947
337 Piedmont Mutual Insurance Co. NC 1,945
338 Club Insurance Co. OH 1,938
339 Conemaugh Valley Mutual Insurance Co. PA 1,896
340 Otsego Co Patrons Coop Fire Relief NY 1,860
341 Southland Lloyds Insurance Co. TX 1,819
342 Centre County Mutual Fire Insurance Co. PA 1,783
343 Great Lakes Mutual Insurance Co. MI 1,752
344 TPA Captive Insurance Co. Inc. GA 1,742
345 Slavonic Mutual Fire Insurance Assoc. TX 1,741
346 Tift Area Captive Insurance Co. GA 1,741
347 Farmington Mutual Insurance Co. WI 1,730
348 Commonwealth Mutual Insurance Co. MD 1,660
349 Vasa Spring Garden Mutual Insurance Co. MN 1,656
350 Lincoln Mutual Insurance Co. NC 1,558
351 Farmers Mech Mutual Insurance Assn. Cecil Cty. MD 1,525
352 Monroe Coop Insurance Co. NY 1,524
353 Distributors Insurance Co. TN 1,521
354 Wallrose Mutual Insurance Co. PA 1,420
355 Indemnity National Insurance Co. KY 1,394
356 Commonwealth Insurance Co. PA 1,380
357 Indiana Old National Insurance Co. IN 1,308
358 Synergy Comp Insurance Co. PA 1,266
359 Farmers Mutual Insurance Co. (MI) MI 1,207
360 Yel Co. Insurance FL 1,198
361 Columbia Federal Insurance Co. DC 1,118
362 Reliamax Insurance Co. SD 1,100
363 Professional Insurance Exchange UT 1,095
364 Oklahoma Property & Casualty Insurance OK 1,084
365 Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance of Branch Cnty MI 1,078
366 Sauquoit Valley Insurance Co. NY 1,045
367 AIOI Insurance Co. of America NY 1,039
368 Grange Mutual Fire Insurance Co. PA 1,018
Topics Florida Carriers Texas New York Auto Louisiana Underwriting Agribusiness New Jersey Property Wisconsin Property Casualty Missouri Casualty Medical Professional Liability
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.
South Carolina Ringleader Sentenced to 8 Years for Staged Accidents 
FBI Says Chinese Hackers Preparing to Attack US Infrastructure 
California Sees Two More Property Insurers Withdraw From Market 
Why New York’s Attorney General Objects to Trump’s Bond Insurer From This Issue
