Skip to content
  • MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
Insurance Journal - Property Casualty Industry News

Featured Stories

  • Lemonade Posts Another Quarterly Loss
  • Tesla Must Pay $243M Over Fatal Autopilot Crash
  • Articles
  • Jobs
  • Markets

Current Magazine

current magazine
  • Read Online
  • Subscribe
  • Login
  • Front Page
    • National
    • International
    • Most Popular
    • Magazine
    • Forums
    • Blogs
    • Videos/Podcasts
    • Newsletters
  • News
    • Most Popular
    • National
    • International
    • East
    • Midwest
    • South Central
    • Southeast
    • West
  • Magazines
  • Research
  • Directories
  • Jobs
  • Features
    • Events
    • Forums
    • Market Directories
    • Quotes
    • Polls
    • Rankings & Awards
    • Insurance Giving Back
  • Subscribe

UK Court Dismisses Climate Case Against Shell in Blow for Activists

By Sam Tobin | July 25, 2023
Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Article

Environmental law charity ClientEarth’s unsuccessful attempt to sue Shell over its climate strategy shows the difficulties in bringing activist shareholder claims, lawyers said on Monday, after London’s High Court dismissed the case.

ClientEarth, which holds 27 shares in Shell, alleges the company cannot achieve its aim of net zero carbon emissions by 2050 with its current climate transition strategy and its directors are therefore breaching their duties to shareholders.

The group wanted to bring a so-called derivative case on behalf of Shell against its directors, which could have seen other firms face investors’ lawsuits over climate-related risks.

ClientEarth Challenges UK Court Dismissal of Shell Climate Lawsuit

However, Judge William Trower refused permission to bring the case. He ruled that ClientEarth’s case ignored that managing large businesses requires directors to “take into account a range of competing considerations,” in which courts should not interfere.

A Shell spokesperson welcomed the ruling and described ClientEarth’s case as “fundamentally flawed.”

Paul Benson, a senior lawyer at ClientEarth, said the charity was disappointed and intended to pursue an appeal.

Teja Pisk, a lawyer at Stevens & Bolton, said the ruling was unsurprising given the high bar for bringing a derivative claim.

But, Pisk added, the decision “will not sound the death knell” for shareholder activism in the environmental, social and governance (ESG) sphere.

Catherine Gilfedder, a partner at law firm Dentons, said ClientEarth’s defeat “re-emphasizes the challenges involved in derivative actions in this area.”

But she also said she thought there would be further cases based on directors’ duties and responsibilities, both in Britain and elsewhere.

Elaina Bailes, a partner at law firm Stewarts, noted that the judge had accepted Shell’s argument that ClientEarth brought the case to further its own policy agenda.

“That is potentially significant for the future use of shareholder claims alleging breach of directors duties,” she said.

The ruling may, however, provide useful guidance to activists considering future claims over directors’ duties and boards’ approaches to climate change, Bailes added.

(Reporting by Sam Tobin; editing by Kylie MacLellan and Mark Potter)

Related:

  • London Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Accusing Shell Board of Climate Failures
Copyright 2025 Reuters. Click for restrictions.

Was this article valuable?

Thank you! Please tell us what we can do to improve this article.

Thank you! % of people found this article valuable. Please tell us what you liked about it.

Here are more articles you may enjoy.

Florida Judge Blocks State Agency for Citizens Claims Disputes, But Insurer Appeals
florida-meteorologists-predictFlorida Meteorologist Predicts Where the Next Hurricane Will Hit–For a Price
US Reversal on Key Climate Finding Spells Uncertainty for Business
Allstate Q2 Income Eclipses $2B as Auto Turns in Combined Ratio of 86

Written By Sam Tobin

More From Author

The most important insurance news,
in your inbox every business day.

Get the insurance industry's trusted newsletter

Email This Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Categories: International & Reinsurance NewsTopics: ClientEarth, Climate Change, climate change lawsuits, climate lawsuits, climate risk management, Directors & Officers, environmental social and governance (ESG) criteria, global warming, Shell
  • Have a hot lead? Email us at newsdesk@insurancejournal.com
More News
Australia’s Privacy Regulator Sues Optus Over 2022 Data Breach
BHP, Vale Offer $1.4B Settlement in UK Lawsuit Over Brazil Mining-Dam Disaster: FT
Digging Into Tesla’s Liability in Crash Case: Where’s the Data?
Surplus Lines Sector Shows 13.2% Rise in Premium Mid-Year: WSIA Report
More News Features

Read This Next

  • UK Court Dismisses Climate Case Against Shell in Blow for Activists
  • Cincinnati Financial More Than Doubles Q2 Net Income
  • 'Soft Market Under Stress' Offers Unique Window of Opportunity for Insurance Buyers
  • Owners of Ship That Crashed Into Baltimore Bridge Sue Vessel's Builder Hyundai
  • Lemonade Posts Another Quarterly Loss but Car Growth Continues

Insurance Jobs

  • Sales Agent - Encino, California
  • Insurance Account Executive/Manager Wanted Flexible Hours, Potential Equity - Dix Hills/Deer Park, NY
  • Early Career Trial Attorney, $10k Sign-on Bonus (Remote – California) - California, CA
  • Underwriting Operations Support – Insurance Carrier – REMOTE - Remote
  • Product Management (Technical) Lead Consultant - Illinois, IL
MyNewMarkets
  • DIY Home Inspections Are Taking Over, Firms Say
  • Six Things to Know About Umbrella Insurance
  • What to Know About Construction and Environmental Liability
  • How Embedded Insurance Supports Real Livelihoods in the Growing On-Demand Economy
  • How to Keep Third-Party Events from Becoming First-Party Losses
Claims Journal
  • Lemonade Posts Another Quarterly Loss But Car Growth Continues
  • Missouri's 2025 Insured Losses From Severe Weather Approaching $2 Billion
  • Prudential in $100M FTC Settlement Over Unit's Healthcare Promises
  • Allstate to Pay About $500K on Georgia Claim Highlighted in Hearing, Senator Says
  • J&J Talc Evidence Gets Review by Ex-Judge at Drugmaker Law Firm
Academy of Insurance education
  • August 7 EPLI Basics
  • August 14 Managing and Insuring Reputational Risk
  • August 19 How To Write: Flood
  • August 21 Workers' Comp Crash Course

Insurance News

  • News by Region
  • News by Topic
  • Yesterday

Site Search

Features

  • Insurance Markets Directory
  • Forums
  • A.M. Best Company Ratings
  • Industry Events
  • Agencies For Sale
  • Newswire
  • Insurance Jobs
  • Rankings & Awards

Connect with us

  • Email Newsletters
  • Magazine Subscriptions
  • For Your Website
  • RSS Feeds
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Do Not Sell My Info

Insurance Journal

  • Submit News
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Reprints
  • Link to Us
  • Contact Us

Wells Media Group Network

  • Insurance Journal
  • MyNewMarkets.com
  • Claims Journal
  • Insurance Journal TV
  • Academy of Insurance
  • Carrier Management
© 2025 by Wells Media Group, Inc. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Site Map