Contractors Object to California Regulator’s Plan to Rehabilitate Majestic Insurance

By | May 20, 2011

Former members of the self-insured workers’ compensation program Contractors Access Program of California, which was managed by now defunct Majestic Insurance Co., have filed a formal objection to the California Department of Insurance’s Majestic Insurance rehabilitation plan.

According to the formal objection, Mark Tanner Construction Inc., Doc Gelso Construction Inc., Mt. Lincoln Construction Inc. and Sierra Paint & Chemical Inc. were members of CAP from 2005 to 2009. They believe Majestic’s actions caused CAP to fail, and that the state Department of Industrial Relations and Department of Insurance failed to take appropriate actions as required by law.

“If the Conservator were to go after the money trail, these objections posit that the reorganization would be unnecessary,” the objection states, noting the DOI’s rehabilitation plan.

The plaintiffs say Majestic owes a duty to CAP members to provide the reinsurance advertised and to reimburse CAP and its members for the unearned premiums that have been transferred to parent CRM Holdings Ltd.

“As it is now structured, the CAP members will be possibly held liable for the wrongdoing of Majestic Insurance Co., and the individuals and entities who profited from the Ponzi-type scheme, Amtrust will benefit significantly without assuming any detriment, and the state of California will rid itself of an embarrassment which, if the regulatory bodies had done their jobs, would never have arisen,” the objection states.

The plaintiffs believe Amtrust (which according to the rehabilitation agreement will be receiving Majestic’s assets) has been involved in the business activities of Majestic since at least 2008, although the extent of the involvement is not known.

“The rehabilitation agreement does not account for the pending litigation by contractors and others in California and the obligations of Majestic Insurance Co. to former members of CAP,” they said, noting they object to excluding Amtrust from any of Majestic’s liability. They requested the DOI amend the agreement to account for some recovery of non-policyholder claims.

The California Department of Industrial Relations declared CAP in default in November 2010 due to insufficient funds.

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.