AM Best Plans to Assess MGAs, Other Delegated Authority Entities

By | March 17, 2021

“What we’ve seen is really an explosion of how much premium is generated from these entities,” said Greg Williams, senior director of Ratings, speaking on a video posted on AM Best’s website. Globally, the amount of premium attributed to DUAEs has doubled in the last decade, he said.

On the video, and in a media statement released Monday, AM Best analysts announced the publication of “Best’s Performance Assessment for Delegated Underwriting Authority Enterprises,” and are requesting comments from industry market participants and other interested parties on the proposed methodology for assessing MGA-like entities outlined in the draft.

Related: Assessing Delegated Underwriting Authorities, MGAs: AM Best Explains

AM Best uses the DUAE acronym to encompass entities other than MGAs, such as managing general underwriters, coverholders, program administrators, program underwriters, underwriting agencies, direct authorizations and appointed representatives.

The common theme, no matter what the title, is that it’s a third-party entity appointed by insurers or reinsurers to perform various functions on their behalf. The functions could include underwriting, claims settlement, or administrative tasks, Williams said in the video.

And that’s what a performance assessment is meant to address—the ability of a DUAE to perform services on behalf of an insurer or reinsurer, said Maura McGuigan, director, Credit Rating Criteria, in the video. She distinguished PAs from financial strength ratings of insurers or reinsurers, noting that DUAEs are not risk-bearing entities.

Historically, insurers and reinsurers have used DUAEs to gain access to specialty and niche markets, broaden distribution and take advantage of their specialty underwriting expertise.

“The Best’s PA is a forward-looking, independent and objective non-credit opinion,” the rating agency said in its press statement.

Separately, McGuigan and Mahesh Mistry, senior director of Credit Rating Criteria, authored an article providing an overview of the five factors that AM Best plans to evaluate to come up with an overall PA. (See related article, “Assessing Delegated Underwriting Authorities, MGAs: AM Best Explains.)

The draft document itself anticipates that new DUAEs, including insurtech MGAs, will seek assessments.

“For example, an InsurTech that wants to increase its profitability may change its business model to that of a DUAE. In other cases, a new company may be more of a traditional startup venture lacking a financial performance history. Due to this, it is likely that AM Best would assess startup DUAEs more conservatively, and their PAs will generally be lower,” the draft document says.

The document goes on to list potential requirements for those entities that have been operating as DUAEs for less than two fiscal years. Among other things, the draft talks about the need for AM Best analysts to be able to review financial statement and a two-year go-forward business plan outlining the DUAE’s partnership criteria and describing products offered and pricing standards, as well as need to have experience management, appropriate staffing and operational infrastructure.

Given the limited public disclosure on MGA-like companies, Williams said he believes the PAs can help DUAEs to better promote themselves, while at the same time giving comfort to insurers and brokers, which can use the PAs to make more informed decisions about partnerships.

AM Best said that written comments on the draft should be submitted in writing by email to methodology.commentary@ambest.com no later than May 3, 2021.

This article first was published in Insurance Journal’s sister publication, Carrier Management.

Topics AM Best Insurance Wholesale

About Susanne Sclafane

Sclafane is Executive Editor of Carrier Management, a publication of Wells Media Group serving property/casualty insurance carrier executives. She is a media professional with deep background in the P/C insurance industry including 25 years as editor and reporter for trade magazines, online news services, digital journals. Her prior experience includes 14 years as a casualty actuary. More from Susanne Sclafane

Was this article valuable?

Here are more articles you may enjoy.