Newer Web Sites Gaining Online Auto Insurance Market Share

March 7, 2011

Newer auto insurance and aggregator sites are attracting an increasing share of the online auto insurance market that has been dominated by GEICO and Progressive, according to a new report.

In the fourth quarter of 2010, these additional sites accounted for 724,000 submitted quotes, making up 8 percent of quotes submitted online, reports, a Reston, Virginia-based firm that specializes in benchmarking online sales.

“The online auto insurance market has been dominated by only a handful of insurers over the past few years, with GEICO and Progressive comprising over 50 percent of all quotes submitted online,” said comScore director Susan Kleinman. “But as more consumers look to the Internet to shop for insurance policies, there is an opportunity for more insurers to break into the online market.”

The comScore online auto insurance benchmarker includes metrics such as visitation and quoting activity for insurance sites. The expanded set of sites saw growth across the board over the past year, with many sites achieving triple-digit gains. led the way among the set of additional sites with 6.5 million visitors, followed by American Family (1.3 million visitors) and Mercury Insurance (686,000 visitors).

Other newer insurance company entries into the online auto insurance marketplace include,,,,,,,,, and

Auto insurers that have been online for awhile and are not considered new entries by comScore include,,,,,,,,,,, and

Insurance Aggregators

In addition to the growing number of individual insurers expanding their reach online, additional insurance aggregators (online agencies and online lead generators) have grown their share of the online auto insurance market due to the entrance of newcomers and the acquisition of existing sites by competitors.

In the fourth quarter 2010, aggregator All Web Leads attracted 6.8 million unique visitors to its sites. Its most visited sites were (1.8 million visitors), (1.3 million visitors), and (1.2 million visitors). (574,000 visitors) and (416,000 visitors) also attracted sizeable audiences.

The analytics firm comScore’s standard auto insurance benchmarker currently includes 13 insurance sites and 7 aggregator sites and provides data on visitation, online quoting, online purchasing and many additional reports such as source of traffic, cross shopping, online servicing, and demographics.

Latest Comments

  • April 28, 2016 at 10:50 am
    Me says:
    Initially I had hopes for internet business' availability. But internet business is typically low yield/high risk business that wants nothing but the lowest-priced legally pa... read more
  • March 10, 2011 at 12:15 pm
    AgencyEquity says:
    The online marketplace actually gives the consumers more choice, it also may save them money as you piont out. But again, it's a marketplace, some may want to do the online th... read more
  • March 9, 2011 at 12:17 pm
    tjmets says:
    All is well for Geico and Progressive but not for the consumer. These companies are low-balling the coverage just to get people in the door. I'm a captive agent and have see... read more
See all comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


More News
More News Features